The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Sugar Beach Resort consistently earns praise for its unbeatable beachfront setting and central, low‑key North Kihei location. Guests love stepping straight onto a long, uncrowded stretch of sand, lingering over sunrise coffee and sunset cocktails on the lanai, and watching outrigger canoes, turtles, and seasonal whales. The vibe is peaceful and family‑friendly, with well‑kept grounds, a pool, hot tub, lawn loungers facing the ocean, clean BBQs, outdoor rinses, and handy on‑site extras like an activity/concierge desk, gear rental, a casual sandwich bar, and even a massage clinic. A bakery, small farmers market, shave ice, and an ABC store are an easy beach walk away, and free/covered parking makes airport runs and day trips to Wailea, Lahaina, Haleakalā, and Upcountry simple.
Most condos are individually owned and many are updated, very clean, and thoughtfully stocked. Travelers frequently note well‑equipped kitchens, in‑unit washer/dryers, strong A/C in many units, comfortable beds, and a trove of beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, boogie boards, snorkels). Hosts are often responsive and proactive with arrival info and local tips, and check‑in is typically smooth.
Common trade‑offs to know: the complex is older and quality varies by unit/manager; a minority of reviews mention dated decor or housekeeping misses, so choose a recently refreshed condo when possible. North Kihei is famously breezy—expect windy afternoons—and Sugar Beach’s fine sand/mud flats can make near‑shore water look brown or choppy at times; it’s fantastic for long walks but not Maui’s best spot for snorkeling or consistently calm swimming (many guests drive south for that). Some units get light road or wind noise, a few report occasional fishy odors from the nearby pond/harbor when the wind shifts, and the original floorplan means small bathrooms and, in some units, bedroom access through the bath. Dining is limited within walking distance beyond the on‑site deli and a few nearby spots, so a car is recommended. If you’re seeking a quiet, centrally located, true‑beachfront condo with great value and views, Sugar Beach fits beautifully; if you want resort glitz, multiple restaurants on site, and crystal‑clear water at your doorstep every day, look elsewhere.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
View was awesome. Bed mostly comfortable. The dryer didn't really dry clothes, took quite a bit of time. Very clean and adequately stocked condo.Was wonderful to have dishwasher pods and laundry soap. Pool, hot tub and sauna were awesome. Always had a seat by the pool. The beach is the best.
Sarah s.
August 2026
The host was very responsive anytime we reached out. When using the shower, the floor beside it would get extremely wet which was right in front of the toilet. There were guest photos that appeared to have a great sunset but for us and this time of year they were hidden by the mountain. The view from the Lanai was great, we ate almost every breakfast and some dinners there. We walked both directions on the beach every day we were there. We initially had an issue with the washer, but it seemed to fix itself although it appears to need a good cleaning. The dryer took quite a long time to dry; dryer vent was directed into the shower area and was in need of a good cleaning. Beach towels and equipment on the Lanai were a nice touch.
Scott W.
August 2026
Super clean place that had all the stuff for enjoying the beach, hanging out on the Lanai, and exploring the island! Good location too. Pool, jacuzzi, sauna, patio was right out the back door and the waterfall/koi pond was a nice bonus!!
Anthony R.
August 2026
The hosts were super friendly and welcoming. The view is amazing. The location is great. I’m not sure if the resort has been hit by the repercussions of the fire because it seemed a little unpopulated, which is good if you like peace and quiet. Very easy to get around from this location.
Tabitha J.
August 2026
Always a great time. Owners are very nice and accommodating. Great beach, pool and grounds. Close enough to stores and restaurants yet, just far enough away, to be away from crowds. I have already booked my return.
Scott M.
August 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
PH 14 is the best condo we have stayed in at Sugar Beach resort. The view is gorgeous, the furniture is very comfortable, the appliances are perfect. The place had ample provisions and was very clean. I will rebook PH 14 again. It was amazing!
Diane D.
August 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was very dirty.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very dissatisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I do not recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
From the first time we entered the condo, we were struck by the strong smell of mildew and dirt. It was the kind of dirty that a vacuum can't clean. Both my sister and I had rashes on our skin until the day after we checked out of that condo. There were bugs in every room every day throughout the day. Mostly pincher bugs. It felt gross to be in there. The flooring and lanai furniture need to be replaced (not the table and chairs but the couch and chaise and all of the cushions). The dishwasher broke while we were there, but the management company got right on it to have it replaced. They also found us new accommodations. They were very kind and responsive.Otherwise, the view from the condo was lovely and the other appliances worked just fine - although we had to buy baking soda for the refrigerator and freezer because they smelled foul. We have stayed at Sugar Beach resort eight times in various condos; this one was by far the most expensive and the yuckiest. I love Sugar Beach resort: the beach, the resort amenities, the pool are all clean, well kept, and thoughtful.
Diane D.
August 2026
We had an incredible stay at this condo in North Kihei! The unit was exceptionally clean, beautifully maintained, and had everything we needed for a relaxing vacation. The beachfront location was hard to beat—we loved being able to walk right onto the beach to enjoy the sunset,The location was also perfect. It was close to restaurants, grocery stores, shopping, and just a short drive to many of Maui’s top attractions, making it easy to explore the island while still enjoying a peaceful place to come back to each day.We couldn’t have been happier with our stay and would absolutely recommend this condo to anyone looking for a comfortable, convenient, and beautiful place to stay in Maui. We would definitely stay here again!
Ryan S.
August 2026
I would say this is the best possible for a stay in Maui.Water 30ft away, the best location, sound and stars possible.
Shannon K.
July 2026
It was like a home away from home. Great facilities, great location, great views. The property and the apartment were well maintained and the lift (elevator) made access from the undercover parking seamless especially when moving luggage.We enjoyed our stay.
David H.
July 2026
Great view! Love staying at Sugar Beach. The condo was just as described and perfect for our 25th anniversary stay. Will book again.
Miguel G.
July 2026
The place was awesome! Enjoyed the location.
Regis H.
July 2026
This stay was above and beyond my expectations. The place was in perfect shape and the views of the ocean were incredible. Communication with the host was very easy. He sent us everything we needed before hand, although there was never an issue that we needed to contact him for during our stay. We couldn't believe we got this gem of a place to stay. We would absolutely stay here again!
Cassy R.
July 2026
My family visited Maui for our 10 year wedding anniversary. Penthouse 1 at Sugar Beach Resort was a perfect location to celebrate the occasion with our two sons (ages 2 and 8 years old). The accommodations were exactly what we needed. The communication and flexibility from the owners of the condo are amazing. I would highly recommend this location to anyone interested in staying in the center of Maui , with the ability to enjoy South Maui, the western part of the island, or Up Country. We will definitely be back!
Mike V.
July 2026
The condo was awesome! It was very clean and had one of the best locations which is literally steps away from the beach.
Garry M.
July 2026
It was a great spot and everything went wonderful.
Jamie F.
July 2026
We absolutely loved this condo ! The view was amazing. The bedroom was beautiful. Had everything we needed and very comfortable. The pool area was great, hot tub chaise lounger’s pool and ocean views ! We had a wonderful week.
david j.
July 2026
Excellent and beautiful accommodations stocked with the necessary kitchen, home and beach needs. Extremely communicative host! Thank you! We hope and will want to return!!!
Thomas Y.
July 2026
Kevin is a great host & this is a really cute property
Miranda B.
July 2026
We enjoyed our stay in this unit.Was clean and had everything we needed.Will definitely be back!
Jared S.
July 2026
We loved it. It was beautiful and comfortable.
Jonathan H.
July 2026
This has been one of the best experiences ever. We stayed here for 10 days and every day was better than the next. This unit was spectacular. It was clean. It was comfortable. It had every possible thing that was needed for our stay. The patio was amazing with amazing furniture. All the furniture in this place was wonderful and high-quality. The location was super easy. You can walk right out the back door to the pool, hot tub and beach. The grounds at this location are kept immaculate. Every morning at 5 AM the people are cleaning the pool and hot tub making sure the grounds are kept pristine. This is the most beautiful VRBO ever. The communication between the Host is perfect and I can go on and on, but this is the best place ever. I highly recommend it.
Joshua K.
July 2026
This place was great. My wife and I stayed 6 nights for our 25th anniversary. Close to all the activities on the island and the condo made you feel at home. Lisa, was great on helping us when we needed anything. I would highly recommend this place to all.Brooks
Brooks T.
July 2026
Beautiful condo with an amazing view of the beach. Kevin was very easy to work with and we loved our stay.
Erin L.
July 2026
The place was just as described. If you are looking for a beach getaway, this place is perfect.
Wilson
July 2026
I think this is the 6th time we have stayed in Sugar Beach 104 and it never disappoints! The best location, perfect amenities and Cara and Sig could not be better hosts. We will see you next year!!
Rich E.
July 2026
The view and the beach is the star here. Great price for what you get. We would definitely stay here again.
Mark M.
July 2026
Great ocean view. Quiet end of Sugar Beach was nice as there wasn’t much beach traffic. The condo was in good shape, had everything we expected, was a little on the small side, but for 2 of us, it was all that we needed. Might just be the time of year (July) but the trade-winds made being outside on the beach or at the pool in the afternoon treacherous. There’s a small restaurant/bar on Property with good sandwiches and drinks but no stores within walking distance. So plan on driving everywhere. The property was quiet and peaceful as far as condo neighbors/residents which was a fantastic change from the other resorts we have stayed in Maui and Oahu. Overall it was a great stay!
David E.
July 2026
Loved our stay! Beautiful home that was perfect for our family!
Jenna W.
July 2026
Amazing views! The location great! Nothing bad to say at all the bed was so comfy! I would recommend 10-10 and will be back!!!!
Esperanza i.
July 2026
We couldn't have asked for a better place. Kitchen is fully equipped with utensils, pots, pans and dishes. Everything was clean and well organized. Actually, we didn't want to leave. The view is amazing and romantic. The bed was very comfortable. I worry making reservations online but this booking was a rare find. This was our first visit to Hawaii and it didn't disappoint. I will definitely book this beautiful condo if we ever get the opportunity to visit again.Thank you so much for allowing us to stay in your beautiful home.
Mary A.
July 2026
We had a wonderful week! The property was clean, bed comfortable, and the view of the ocean from the balcony stunning! Would recommend this place 100%!
Edie G.
July 2026
Beautiful condo, great communications with Sue. Highly recommend this unit with exceptional pool and ocean view. Would absolutely look at staying again.
July 2026
Our stay at Sugar Brach was amazing! Beautiful beach front views. We loved listening to the waves at night. Mike and Brenda are such amazing hosts, very attentive for every little detail. Definitely want to come back to this beautiful Pent House and island with it being in such a great location, makes it easy to get everywhere.
Brandy M.
July 2026
Clean and quiet, had everything that I needed
Greg C.
July 2026
This condo worked perfectly for our group of 4. It was well stocked with everything we needed. Lots of cabinets held any item we needed for our trip which was very appreciated. The condo is way bigger than the pictures show and the view cannot be beat! The pool and hot tub were never crazy busy and were always clean. I would highly recommend this condo to anyone and hopefully I can visit soon and rent this unit again.
Kristi M.
July 2026
We have stayed at your property twice and we love the location of the ground floor location. About 10 feet to pool 20 to beach of you turn right out of your condo and left if you want good food at dina sandwitch or a good drink they have a nice bar. Best food you can eat in or to go. Met so many amazing people. Also whether you have small children, middle aged or adults this facility is so welcoming. The pool has a very nice pool a child's pool up above the regular pool and a jacuzzi not to mention a sauna. You cant go wrong with Sugar Beach Resort only about 16 minutes from landing at OGG.A special Thank you to our hosts that always make is feel welcomed with a special card welcoming you.
Teresa F.
July 2026
No dishes & no hot water so be prepared - nice view, nice clean place. Love Sugar Beach Resorts.
Debra H.
July 2026
Mike and Brenda were amazing hosts! They really care about their guests experience, and were so accommodating! We were bumped up to their penthouse unit and it was so private, and had a killer view! 10 stars!
Rachel D.
July 2026
Excited to return. The food service was great and the staff spot on. Enjoyed the beach and even saw turtles while snorkeling. Could not be more pleased with Alii Resort Hosts.
Karen S.
July 2026
Perfect condo for a couples getaway. Condo was clean, stocked and location is excellent. No need to rent beach gear when you stay here. Condo comes w beach chairs, umbrellas, coolers, beach towels, and 2 snorkel sets. Strongly recommend this unit for any couple looking for a quiet, relaxing stay or anyone exploring west and south Maui (centrally located). Plenty of free parking, pool area and grounds are clean. Elevators and shopping carts make grocery runs and hauling luggage/beach equipment a breeze. Host communication was fantastic. We’ll be back!
Jason G.
July 2026
Great place. Great location. Would stay again.
Jay F.
July 2026
Great location - close to just about anything!
Chris N.
July 2026
The balcony is enormous with an amazing view of the ocean! My family of 4 adults had plenty of room to relax. All of the provided beach equipment (chairs, boogie boards, snorkel gear) and being so close to the ocean made our many trips to the beach delightful. The furniture was comfortable for sitting and sleeping. The AC and fans kept things cool and comfortable at night and during the day we enjoyed keeping all the windows and sliding doors open. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay.
Levianne M.
July 2026
This location cannot be beat. You've got a fantastic view, right on the beach, and a central location that makes it easy to get most places on the island. The bathroom is a little small, but overall it makes a fine place for a couple to explore Maui.
Jeremy and Sara L.
July 2026
We absolutely loved this place!!
Gonzalo J.
July 2026
The co do was amazing. The view was incredible. The host was very responsive. Everything in the pictures match and you have all the cooking utensils you'll need.
Mia R.
July 2026
Beautiful condo and had everything we needed! Made our trip so relaxing.
David B.
July 2026
Clean, and everything needed was provided. Easy to reach host, check in was smooth. Good location and view. Pool was warm, elevator was helpful. Easy access to town close by for anything else. Short drive, but people do drive super slow, lol.
Laura H.
July 2026