The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Kihei Bay Surf delivers a laid-back, budget-friendly condo experience in North Kihei, with its standout feature being the location: it’s directly across the street from Kalepolepo Beach and the Humpback Whale Sanctuary/fishpond where guests frequently watch sea turtles haul out at sunset. Travelers love using it as a central home base for exploring Maui—quick drives to Wailea, Upcountry, West Maui, and the Road to Hana—then returning for sunsets, a dip in the pool or hot tub, and casual BBQs. The vibe is friendly and low-key, and many reviewers say they’d happily return.
Most units are cozy studios best for couples or small families and are generally described as clean, comfortable, and very well stocked. Expect full kitchens, beach gear (chairs, towels, coolers; often snorkel sets), and thoughtful touches like “pay‑it‑forward” pantries. Hosts and managers—especially in the units run by highly rated owners—earn consistent praise for fast, helpful communication and easy self check‑in. The complex amenities (pool, hot tub, tennis court, BBQs, free parking) are well maintained, and while views are often partial or garden-facing, the beach access is immediate.
Trade-offs reflect an older complex with individually owned condos: some units are freshly renovated while others feel dated. A recurring theme is road noise for units facing South Kihei Road and early-morning maintenance near the pool; interior or courtyard-facing units tend to be quieter. AC effectiveness varies by unit and sun exposure, so afternoons can run warm; fans and cross‑breezes help. As with many Hawaii stays, occasional ants or pests pop up if food is left out, and a few guests noted sporadic cleaning misses that hosts typically addressed quickly. Shared laundry exists but has at times been under maintenance or app-operated, and unassigned parking can mean a short walk when busy. If you’re sensitive to noise or heat, consider requesting an interior/upper unit and confirming AC details; keep food sealed, and check laundry status ahead of time. Overall, the value, location, and easy beach access are the big wins here.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
The accommodation was just as described and shown in the photos! The only issue we had were hundreds of little gnats but we were told it was because of the recent rainfall!
Cindy
May 2026
Very nice place to stay!
Brayden T.
May 2026
This was a great stay! Thank you, Kevin. Very communicative and helpful. It was a 4-5 mins walk by the ocean. Which is pretty cool! Everything you need is there and he provided beach chairs, umbrella, towels and cooler for use. It was clean and had no issues.
Laidee Hannina F.
May 2026
Great value for the location. A-minute walk to the beach. 5- min drive to the super market. Air condition was a little too weak for us. But we were not in the unit anyway during the day.
Gizzy C.
May 2026
Great stay. Good communication from host. Perfect location. Clean room. 5 stars all around!! Thank you.
Elizabeth K.
May 2026
Clean room, felt very homey! Across the street from a park/beach (was closed due to Kona storms but still convenient for others when not closed). Everything was a 5-10 min drive away in kihei. I absolutely loved and enjoyed the birds that would visit on the porch. There was also a drying rack out there that was VERY useful. No check in, just a code so that was also convenient.
I got engaged here so it holds a special place in my heart.
Thank you for a great room for our wonderful maui experience.
Raven
May 2026
The property is located close to the ocean, making it a lovely spot for sunset walks. The swimming pool and BBQ area are clean and well-maintained. The unit is fully equipped with all the essentials and more. I gave it 4 stars mainly due to cleanliness issues—particularly the towels, which had an unpleasant smell
Yekaterina
May 2026
Was happy with my stay. Very comfortable and had all the things I needed for the beach.
Valentina C.
April 2026
Could not see the beach, that’s ok. We had a nice view of the pool. It was nice to sit out on the balcony to drink my coffee. The Room was clean & tidy. Owners had everything available, beach equipment, towels, kitchen condiments. The air conditioner worked well.
Amanda F.
April 2026
Air conditioning was great! Small unit but worked great. Great place for a unit
Kaley C.
April 2026
Parking is great. The pool and bbq area is fantastic. Pool is super clean! The laundromat on store was not in service which was unwelcome. But other than that everything else was tops.
Danny
April 2026
This is a great property in a great location.
Pam R.
April 2026
No beach view but a clean comfortable place
cheryl M.
April 2026
The place and location are good, however at night the place became infested with bugs. I have been coming to Maui many years however I haven’t had that issue before. I was not able to tell if they were coming through the vents or the front door, but it was very bad and uncomfortable to sleep in. If the bug problem can get fixed this would be a great place.
Mitchell G.
April 2026
Beach view was partial. Its ok. It was very convenient for family activities. Overall it was pleasant safe and comfortable
Raquel F.
April 2026
Well located, comfortable, clean, and well appointed with snorkel gear and beach fun.
Jay S.
April 2026
Place was really enjoyable, great location!
Ben M.
April 2026
Kitchen was stocked with everything needed, quiet comfortable accommodations
Virginia D R.
April 2026
Great stay and location.
olivia h.
April 2026
Great place to stay. Clean, comfortable, had everything we needed. Pool and hot tub and beach supplies were a plus. Thank you! We will for sure stay here again.
Sarah S.
April 2026
Unit was clean and tastefully updated. Check in was easy. Highly recommend.
Rose B.
April 2026
The condo was what I expected. The standing air conditioner was loud that was disruptive while trying to sleep. Filters needed to be cleaned or possibly replaced.
April 2026
Clean room, well maintained.
Navaneeth C.
April 2026
The stay was very pleasant. The studio is quite spacious and fully equipped. The location is great, right across the street from the beach and just a 5-minute drive to a mall with a variety of shops and restaurants.
The host provided very clear instructions at all times, so there was no confusion. The pool and jacuzzi were in excellent condition. We even asked for a late check-out by a few hours and they kindly accommodated us.
I highly recommend it.
Maria Fernanda
April 2026
This is a great place to stay for a host of reasons: The host is extremely communicative and attentive to the needs of guests. The place is clean and the ammenities are in excellent condition and in close proximity to rooms. By ammenities I mean pool, spa, tennis courts, and laundry room. The location is clean on the outside as well as inside. The place was well stocked with basic items and then some. Everything was in working order and you feel secure when staying here, not to mention that you had a beach and small museum across the street, and are close by to shopping and stores. Bonus: You really can’t beat the price. There are boogie boards and beach chairs in good shape for use as well.We thoroughly enjoyed our stay here, and will be coming back. If you do stay here, keep something in mind: Always try and leave the place how you found it…or better.
Erick H.
April 2026
Just what I was looking for. The property was clean, comfortable and the amenities were what you would expect for an island property. I will rebook this unit for future visits.
Jay K.
March 2026
Everything was excellent. I will let people know this is the place to stay when on island.
Nikki B.
March 2026
Thank you Laura for your help (even when I was cranky and couldn’t find my room). Thank you for helping me settle in!
March 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Loved it
Garett J.
March 2026
Great location and overall great renovated studio with tons of equipment and accessories. Unfortunately, we needed to checkout early due to the South Kihei flooding. The host was understanding of the situation and was able to refund us for the days we did not stay, and we are thankful for that. I hope everyone is recovering from all the storming. Would definitely recommend under better weather conditions.
Victor R.
March 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was more than happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
I only stayed three nights, just a stop over to visit relatives done the road. Then on to the big island. I found the bed very comfortable and was lucky to get a good cross breeze through the room. I would definitely stay here again, a nice beach right across the street with easy access.
A guest from Las Vegas, NV
March 2026
Clean and well maintained
Pool and hot tub were also clean and well maintained
Our accommodation and everything we needed and manager was very professional and communicated all the details with us in advance
Marise
March 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
We were faced with heavy rains and flooding.We had no power for 2 days which was rough but our accommodation was clean and comfortable.We asked for a late checkout on our last day so we could make up for lost time and the management company was so generous and said no problem and they didn’t charge was nice to know they were so reachable I’d we needed anything.We will be back!The pool and hot tub were well maintained and nice to have as well.
Marise O.
March 2026
Every one did the best they could do considering they were cleaning up after a major storm
Nikki B.
March 2026
No issues. As described
dave t.
March 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Great stay! Well stocked condo
Brad A.
March 2026
We came here to celebrate our 40th wedding anniversary.First time coming to Hawaiin island.Wonderful condo as advertised.Great location and communicative host.Hallie has thought of everything: beach chairs, cooler, flashlight, all the kitchen utensils needed, plenty of towels.Great location for a reasonable price.Thanks Hallie!
Heidi H.
March 2026
Our stay was great! The location was great, the property manager was very responsive, the shade umbrella was broken when we arrived but we messaged the manager and they brought us a new one the next day it was great. Loved our stay here.
Damon W.
March 2026
Place was great!
Jerry N.
March 2026
Kevin was fantastic - last minute booking and went out of his way to accommodate us! Very nice studio, clean, well stocked - great location! Would rent again...
Kenn G.
March 2026
The condo was beautiful. Very clean and comfortable. I had a great stay.
Trish P.
March 2026
Everything was great, very professional and responded to messages quickly!
Kellen M.
March 2026
Great beach amenities!
Wendy K.
March 2026
Our host was Maui Rentals and they were awesome. The owner did a beautiful job on the Reno.
March 2026
The location across the street from a public access to the beach was fantastic! The studio apartment was comfortable and supplied with all we needed for our 10-day stay. We appreciated the comfortable queen-sized bed, dresser and closet for unpacking clothes, and futon couch beyond a small dining table and chairs. We used the beach towels and chairs and the ESSENTIAL ice chest, too! We only had time to enjoy the pool and spa on a few occasions, a pleasant addition to amenities. We became fans of the two nearby food cart pods when not cooking for ourselves. Kevin, the host, was easy to reach and quick to respond to our needs.
Christine C.
March 2026
Mahalo for having such a wonderful unit.The unit is perfect. Very nice. Clean and beautiful.It is in a great location.Sand and sunsets across the way.Snorkeling and whale watching down at the Kihei boat ramp.
Randy C.
March 2026
Our host had some good tips for things to do & places to eat.Being across the street from the ocean was amazing!
Karen F.
March 2026
yes mostly amenity and host helped when i needed a fridge when i was not yet in my time frame
steve t.
February 2026
Overall, we had a good stay. The location is great as it's close to the beach with free parking. We really appreciated the beach chairs, snorkel masks, and pool noodles, and the front hose area was convenient for rinsing off. It would’ve been nice if basic toiletries (shampoo, conditioner, body wash) were included, though they did provide sunscreen which was thoughtful. We did notice a few small bugs, but that seemed fairly normal given the top mesh door opening. There was an issue with the sink, but management responded quickly and had it replaced the next day. It felt a bit pricey for the condition, but that’s pretty typical for Maui.
Adrianna H.
February 2026
The condo was very clean. The bed was comphy too.
Martha P.
February 2026