The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Staying at Menehune Shores feels quintessentially oceanfront: you’re steps from the sand with sweeping lanai views of Maalaea Bay, nightly sunsets, and in-season whale sightings. A unique highlight is the historic rock fishpond right out front, which creates a shallow, protected lagoon that’s ideal for kids and calmer swims; sea turtles regularly rest on the rocks here. Guests love the quiet, well-kept grounds, heated pool (heater occasionally down), big grassy lawn, shuffleboard, and the panoramic rooftop with BBQs and a convivial sunset vibe. The North Kihei location is central for exploring Maui (Wailea, Haleakalā, Road to Hana, airport), yet feels laid back and uncrowded.
Condos vary by owner, but the overall theme is clean, comfortable, and well-equipped. Many units are updated and thoughtfully stocked with beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, snorkel sets), full kitchens, and in‑unit laundry; hosts and managers are frequently praised as responsive and accommodating. Some units have efficient mini‑split A/C in bedrooms/living areas, while others rely on trade winds, ceiling fans, and cross‑breezes; most guests report sleeping comfortably with windows open. Nice pluses: easy beach access, a quick walk to Kalepolepo Beach Park and the Humpback Whale Sanctuary, rooftop grilling, and an onsite Indian restaurant (Monsoon) that many enjoy.
Good to know: this is an older, well‑maintained complex, and individual units differ in décor and features—read the specific listing for A/C coverage, shade on the lanai, and recent updates. Afternoons can be windy, and the bay water here is often shallow and can look murkier than the postcard‑blue beaches; for clearer snorkeling or bigger waves, plan short drives to Wailea/Kapalua. Common nits mentioned across reviews include tight parking stalls and occasional road noise in end units, sporadic pool heater outages or maintenance closures (no hot tub), limited shade at the pool/roof, and the rare cleanliness or pest issue that’s typically addressed when reported. Overall sentiment is strongly positive: guests highlight the views, turtle encounters, central convenience, and family‑friendly setting—and many say they’d happily return.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
Beautiful condo!!! Clean, well stocked, great ocean view. Would definitely stay here again!
Katie L.
June 2026
Fun place to stay and a good location.
Joshua H.
June 2026
The room floors were not mopped, dirty. Had ants daily. For the price I expected better.
Joyce H.
June 2026
Generally after a longer vacation (especially with three young children), you might be a little ready to get back home to your comfort zone. Well, 605 was that comfort zone for us. We were all legitimately sad to leave and when we return to Maui, it will definitely be at the top of our list of places to stay. The hosts were incredibly kind and responsive through the whole process, and the condo was honestly more than we had even hoped for. Thank you!!!!!
Dan B.
June 2026
The view is stunning. The place has everything you need
Santiago G.
June 2026
Great condo in a convenient location. Loved the oceanfront lanai for sunrise and sunset views. The unit was well equipped in both the kitchen and for the beach with chairs and boogie boards. Would definitely recommend it and hope to come back ourselves.
Mark W.
June 2026
Having traveled throughout the country many times-what I can tell you about this property is that it was extremely clean, well run, pool-awesome, beach access-awesome, location to restaurants and activities -great. I appreciated the quiet hours. I took my grandkids on vacation with us-there were beach toys, fishing poles, towels, beach umbrella, and goggles to use. The kids had a great time! Amenities were all included and appreciated.
Donna W.
June 2026
Location: AmazingHost: Super responsive, patient and provided great information.Condo: Clean and perfect size for a family of 4.Building: GoodView: AmazingWould definitely recommend and stay here again if/when visiting in future.
Srinivas S.
June 2026
lanai view was excellent
DON P.
June 2026
Everything was excellent. Check in was easy. The pool is very nice. Rooms are comfortable and the kitchen was well stocked with everything you could need and more. View is nice of the beach and ocean. No complaints and couldn't be happier.
Jonathan P.
June 2026
We absolutely loved this condo and Chad was a wonderful host!! The view was incredible. Thank you for an awesome stay!
stephanie a.
June 2026
Great. Thank you
J J.
June 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Fab condo and super accommodating and helpful management company!
Gemma H.
June 2026
Super clean property, friendly staff and great excellent location!
Kim A.
June 2026
Nice room with great view. Convenient to all beaches.
Pam R.
June 2026
We really enjoyed our stay at this property! The proximity to the beach is great and Kihei is a quiet little town with a lot of great local restaurants with a WIDE variety of food offerings. The condo is well-maintained and really had everything we needed after a grocery store run. The rooftop area was great for sunsets and the lanai was small, but had a great view! Beds were comfortable, linens and towels were fine, coffee pot and full size fridge were great. Hosts were very responsive.
Leslie A.
June 2026
Condo was great for what we needed it for. Close in location to many shops and restaurants. Beds were very comfortable
ASHLEY B.
June 2026
![Menehune Shores 518]()
Our stay at Menehune Shores was absolutely wonderful! The condo was comfortable, clean, and well-maintained, making it feel like a home away from home. The bedrooms were cozy and inviting, and we had everything we needed for a relaxing and enjoyable vacation.The highlight of our stay was the incredible ocean view from the balcony. We were so close to the water that we could hear the waves rolling onto the shore throughout the day and night. Enjoying our morning coffee while watching the ocean was an experience we will never forget.Chad was an exceptional host. He was responsive, respectful, and attentive to all our inquiries. He made sure we had a great experience during our stay.I would highly consider returning to this condo and would recommend it to anyone visiting Maui. The location, comfort, breathtaking views, and outstanding hospitality made it the perfect place to stay. Although we traveled throughout the island, there is plenty of everything in Kīhei and nearby vicinity to make this location your primary destination.Mahalo from the Gimenez family from Southern California
Maria O.
June 2026
Really nice location close to (within a short driving distance) the restaurants and bars and stores. Beautiful views. More than enough room for the 5 people we had stay. The condos are very quite: you do not hear your neighbors at all. The beaches within walking distance to the left of the condo are rocky at the shoreline, and the rocked-in area has some big rocks you will stub your toe on as you wade out to see the turtles, but well worth it to see all of the turtles that come up on the beach. The water near the shore is murky on most days. We drove to lots of other beaches within 15-20 minutes south on South Kihei Road. South Kihei Road can get noisy, but it is usually not bad at all.
Tana D.
June 2026
The grounds at this property are meticulously maintained. The pool, chairs, grill… everything was perfectly scrubbed. The condo itself was well stocked with everything we could possibly need and the pictures are spot on. We loved being able to walk down and see the turtles in the morning. If it is your first time in Maui, plan your excursions for the afternoon so you can enjoy the calm beach weather in the morning.
Kimberly S.
June 2026
Absolutely beautiful property exactly as described. I’ve stayed at menehune shores before and it never disappoints. It’s a perfect location and super quiet I love being able to hear the waves. Such a beautiful home can’t wait to come back
Callie F.
June 2026
It was an ocean front not really a beach front. It was clean but very outdated for the price.
May 2026
We loved our stay. Gorgeous views and great location. Would stay again
Matthew K.
May 2026
![Azure Bay]()
One of the best units we've ever stayed in. Loved the cleanliness, accuracy of unit description, promptness of May responding to inquiries, how tastefully the unit is decorated/painted which made us really feel like we were on a tropical vacation. Mostly we appreciated all May's attention to detail...like how the unit was stocked: kitchen has everything you would ever want in a rental, including spices, sharp knives (little details...so many times we have stayed in units with dull knives that I always bring a hand knife sharpener when we travel...didn't need it here). One of the very best things is the Brita water filter in the fridge, and the funnel to pour filtered water into our water bottles...huge money saver over buying bottled water daily. And other details like convenient and space saving drawers in the bed frame. Also, Menehune Shores is hands down our favorite place to stay when we visit Maui...central island access for driving West Maui, Hana, Upcountry... awesome sunsets, lots of turtles, morning beach walks. I could go on, but you get the picture...outstanding unit that we highly recommend.
Jim R.
May 2026
The condo is perfectly located and stockedwith kitchen and beach basics. The washer and dryer were great and we appreciated the quick wash setting. The beds were very comfortable and kept us rested and ready for the day. This was our second time staying at Menehune Shores and love how spotless the grills and pool area are kept. We did have a couple of hiccups but Sharon was quick to respond and communicate. We would absolutely stay again!
Susan M.
May 2026
Beautiful place the stay with an incredible view!
Chelsea L.
May 2026
Great place! Very peaceful with a breathtaking view.
Emily M.
May 2026
This is a beautiful condo. It's right on the ocean and the deck is a great place to sit back watch the sun set and listen to the waves roll in. There are some nice places to eat in the vicinity. The unit was very clean and comfortable.
Karen H.
May 2026
Our second stay in this beautiful unit! Can’t wait for a trip in the future
Kelly N.
May 2026
On the beach right next to the pool! A lot of extras that I did not expect to be there like umbrella, chairs, sand toys, even a crib. Washer and dryer worked great. Great location to everything if you’re gonna do the road to Hana make sure you do some research and download off-line maps.
EUGENE BISE B.
May 2026
Newly remodeled, new appliances, very clean, all the necessary amenities. Mattress was outstanding. Needs more pillows though.
Robert K.
May 2026
The view was even BETTER than advertised!! We love Menehune Shores and found this listing, will definitely find this condo again for next time! Also, the bed was incredibly comfortable, very important for travelers in their late 30's!
Ashley R.
May 2026
Overall a great stay! Affordable and a wonderful location. Only downfall was how hot the unit got without AC. We were expecting the windows open and ocean winds at night would cool it down a bit but even with all the fans, it still was around 80 at night (same as during the day) in the condo. Not the hosts fault because they did advertise accurately just something to know if you are used to AC! Wonderful little beach for kids and if you need an affordable place to stay and are used to warmer weather, this is a great spot.
Carlee D.
May 2026
Look no further. Book it now. Views were better than pictured in the listing. Very well appointed furnishings and stocked kitchen. Beach chairs, snorkel, cooler, and umbrella were awesome. Super quiet at all times of the day and night. Extremely well kept condo complex. Safe and convenient to everything. Everything was included for a plug and play vacation.
Mike Y.
May 2026
Wonderful place as described!
Dean H.
May 2026
Fabulous location!
Susan
May 2026
Great spot, steps from the beach. Owner was quick and responsive. Unit was clean.
Brian J.
May 2026
Pamela, the host, always responded immediately to messages. The unit is PERFECT for couples and the view can’t be beat. We loved eating breakfast out on the lanai. Eating dinner was also nice, depending on what time it was. The sunset can be overwhelming. The location was also great for our planned activities. I would definitely stay here again.
Rob & Cindy S.
May 2026
Everything was great! Beach was dirty from the storm but pool was nice!
Lee D.
May 2026
We enjoyed our stay in this condo. Appreciated the ease of check in and location was great to get everywhere in Maui. Easy parking and well stocked apartment.
Randi M.
May 2026
The condo layout was exactly as described and worked perfectly for our group of five, with plenty of space for everyone to spread out comfortably. The kitchen was well stocked, and there were ample towels and essentials provided for our stay.We especially appreciated the personal greeting upon arrival—it was a thoughtful touch that helped answer all of our questions right away. Parking was easy and convenient, with plenty of available spaces throughout our visit.The views were absolutely spectacular and truly a highlight of the stay.We would stay here again and recommend it to others
Penny G.
April 2026
This place was clean, view excellent- enjoyed the sunsets! Host was very helpful. Not much beach in front of the seawall due to tide, in a few months the beach to the left as you face the ocean should be cleaned up if the crew continues the work on it. Under construction while we visited. All in all and excellent property!
David P.
April 2026
We had a great stay at the condo. Jim was quick to respond to our questions about the March storms that hit and reassured us that everything would be ready for our visit. Once inside there was everything we could possibly need - beach toys, chairs, plenty of towels, and more! The condo was undergoing some routine maintenance and Jim was quick to share the information with us so we could plan our time accordingly. Overall we had a great stay! Thank you Speth Family!
Brianna M.
April 2026
Our stay was great!! Our place had everything that was needed for cooking & beach fun!!
kena b.
April 2026
![Menehune Shores]()
We stayed for 10 days and thoroughly enjoyed our first trip to Maui! Location of this place is fantastic.. steps away from the beach (which we walked every morning), plus you are a few minutes drive away from the busier areas of Kihei. It's super quiet within the unit.. we couldn't hear anyone above or below us, which was really nice. A/C in both bedrooms living room was superb. Other conveniences such as key code locking, beach supplies (umbrellas, chairs, etc), laundry, and a well stocked kitchen really adds to the value of the unit. We would not hesitate to book again. Menehune Shores is a very enjoyable place to stay. We took full advantage of the pool and there is a bar/restaurant located right downstairs. Just a couple of minor improvements that could be made would be to update the bed linens and curtains in the unit. Also, there is no lock on the patio door, but this isn't a big deal as you are on the third floor. Honestly, don't hesitate to book this place, you won't be disappointed!
Cedric M.
April 2026
We had five in our group and had an excellent stay. There was plenty of room for all of us and everything that we could possibly need was supplied. Location was perfect for us to get out and explore. The views were amazing and though we didn’t use it much the roof was a great place to sit and socialize. We ate at the Monsoon Grill which was very convenient and tasty. Would definitely stay here again if ever in Maui.
Gary Y.
April 2026
What a fantastic property! May was such a great host! Great communication, check-in/check-out was a piece of cake! The condo was super clean with a fantastic ocean view. This is a great location if you are traveling around the island, plus great food and shopping nearby. This is a great place to stay!
Kelley S.
April 2026
Perfect beach vacation condon for my family. We were 4 adults and 2 kids, and thoroughly enjoyed the property. Will def. stay here again if we come back to Maui.
Karthik B.
April 2026
Our stay at the condo was very nice. Loved being right on the beach. Especially loved watching the sunsets from the roof top as well as the blowing of the conch shell ritual at the sunset.
Donna B.
April 2026