The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Staying at Menehune Shores feels quintessentially oceanfront: you’re steps from the sand with sweeping lanai views of Maalaea Bay, nightly sunsets, and in-season whale sightings. A unique highlight is the historic rock fishpond right out front, which creates a shallow, protected lagoon that’s ideal for kids and calmer swims; sea turtles regularly rest on the rocks here. Guests love the quiet, well-kept grounds, heated pool (heater occasionally down), big grassy lawn, shuffleboard, and the panoramic rooftop with BBQs and a convivial sunset vibe. The North Kihei location is central for exploring Maui (Wailea, Haleakalā, Road to Hana, airport), yet feels laid back and uncrowded.
Condos vary by owner, but the overall theme is clean, comfortable, and well-equipped. Many units are updated and thoughtfully stocked with beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, snorkel sets), full kitchens, and in‑unit laundry; hosts and managers are frequently praised as responsive and accommodating. Some units have efficient mini‑split A/C in bedrooms/living areas, while others rely on trade winds, ceiling fans, and cross‑breezes; most guests report sleeping comfortably with windows open. Nice pluses: easy beach access, a quick walk to Kalepolepo Beach Park and the Humpback Whale Sanctuary, rooftop grilling, and an onsite Indian restaurant (Monsoon) that many enjoy.
Good to know: this is an older, well‑maintained complex, and individual units differ in décor and features—read the specific listing for A/C coverage, shade on the lanai, and recent updates. Afternoons can be windy, and the bay water here is often shallow and can look murkier than the postcard‑blue beaches; for clearer snorkeling or bigger waves, plan short drives to Wailea/Kapalua. Common nits mentioned across reviews include tight parking stalls and occasional road noise in end units, sporadic pool heater outages or maintenance closures (no hot tub), limited shade at the pool/roof, and the rare cleanliness or pest issue that’s typically addressed when reported. Overall sentiment is strongly positive: guests highlight the views, turtle encounters, central convenience, and family‑friendly setting—and many say they’d happily return.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
Beautiful view and was clean…however there were some small roaches in the bathroom and I didn’t feel super comfortable after that!! They scurried under the sink when I turned the light on in the middle of the night…yuck! Luckily we have family here so we ended up not using it the second night. I understand it’s a warm climate and bugs will happen but it might be time for another spraying. I will probably choose something that doesn’t connect with so many people next time.
August 2025
Perfect location and very well kept complex. The room was basic but all a person needs. The washer could be replaced as it does not clean the dishes very well, and the front door needs to be repaired as it does not seal at the bottom at all.
John K.
August 2025
Sharon and her property are great! Easy to get to, easy to access (so great that the property has an elevator) comfortable and delightful furnishings - everything was super. Sharon's responsiveness to questions is the best and she has her home "stocked" so very well. Get to the unit before you make a store run. You may not need to purchase those condiments, etc, that you thought you might need! Great time!
Tom & Karen T.
August 2025
Communication with host was good.Very well located.We never got the the parking permit because we got there after office closed and rest of the days we were out exploring and never got it, but no problem we always left a note. Hope it was easy for next visit and no have to worried about parking.
Aymara G.
August 2025
Everything went smoothly from check in to accommodations except that when the earthquake occurred in Russia and the tsunami warning sirens when off, it was some time until property manager reached out and the condo association only provided a map showing we were in the evacuation area, but not where we should go for higher ground. Being visitors to Maui this was quite confusing and anxiety producing.Oceanfront sunset views were wonderful! We are repeat visitors to Menehune Shores.
Teri L.
August 2025
Check in was super easy. The kitchen is fully set with plates ,pots, silverware, some seasoning left from previous guest. The pool was very nice. We saw turtles daily. They have binoculars to look out at the water which was very nice. If you like Indian food the restaurant is very good(according to my kids) The one think I missed and was totally my fault is there is no air. At night it does get windy so that cools it off. They have plenty of fans . The view is amazing. The location of this condo is perfect distance from airport and things to do. You should rent a car to enjoy the island. There are beach chairs, cookers and beach toys also. Make sure you enjoy the sunset.
Crystal P.
August 2025
As advertised! Chad was great to work with and more than accommodating. We had a great time in Kihei. Highly recommend!
Julia W.
July 2025
The good:Had everything we needed and more! It was great to have travel mugs, coolers, beach chairs available for our adventures Beds were comfy, linens were plentiful and clean. Proximity to walk to the beach and pool was great. Good location to get to all parts of the island quickly. Good access to nearby shops & restaurants Not necessarily a pro/con, more of an observation, there were rules posted EVERYWHERE. Not just in the condo but throughout the property as well. Never just felt comfortable to just relax without the fear of breaking a rule, especially at the pool. Overall a good stayThe bad:We had a bit of a hiccup with our stay as the AC went out before check in and were given the option to stay or be relocated to another property. We decided to stay with a discount. The open windows helped with the heat, was cool at night but a bit stuffy during the day. Place was clean though the bathrooms were a bit outdated and didn’t look as clean. The shampoo/conditioner/body wash dispensers were broken (there was no sign) and we didn’t know. Some old stale water came out of them that was stinky/rancid. There were mini bottles of shampoo/conditioner/body wash on the counter we could use. There were small ants everywhere so we had to put everything away to keep them out of stuff. This may have been seasonal but there was construction right outside of our bedroom window with loud trucks and excavators starting up at 5am. Just beware if you’re a light sleeper.
Janie R.
July 2025
It was great. I loved the location and the turtles.
Lori H.
July 2025
Very enjoyable stay
Kara G.
July 2025
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Mahalo Viktoria and the whole team for constantly being in touch while our stay at your property. It was a beautiful cozy condo for my family, great proximity to everything, grocery, gas, coffee, sights. We had an amazing time. Mahalo again.
Arsalan M.
July 2025
The property was nice condo was not
Cheryl S.
July 2025
Everything in the listing was exactly as noted and the owners were a pleasure to deal with. The location is very central - great for exploring all that Maui has to offer.
Bob L.
July 2025
This property was beautiful, I had an amazing experience staying here relaxing on the balcony with the sound of the ocean so peaceful. Can’t wait to go back and stay here again!!!
Sheila O.
July 2025
Great location. First floor was awesome with access to the grass and beach right from our patio. Wind in the afternoon prevented any outdoor activity. No air conditioning was a surprise!
Wendy M.
July 2025
Convenient location with great views.
sudhir h.
July 2025
Extremely comfortable and clean property. Enjoyed relaxing on the lenai every evening to watch the sunset. Kitchen had all the cooking equipment we needed, even a crockpot. Folks at Ali'i Resorts were very responsive to all our requests. Things to know: Kihei gets very windy in the afternoon. Very, very windy. We had to go elsewhere on the island to relax on the beach and avoid the wind starting around noon. Wind dies down in the early evening. There is a Safeway nearby for grocery shopping to stock up the kitchen. Five minute drive or a 20-minute walk. The Beach Club, a short walk up the street has a nice happy hour and a great patio for overlooking the water. Friendly service.
John C.
July 2025
We had a wonderful Maui Vacation at this condo. The location was centralized on the West Coast of Maui so you can get anywhere on the island very easily and is a quick trip to the airport or the resort area of Wailea. The property owners were fantastic. Checking on us prior to check in and helping out with multiple request such as providing a needed air mattress and allowing us a late check out due to a later flight departure. Overall a wonderful time at an extremely accommodating and very nice condo with a beautiful sunset view.
Keith S.
July 2025
We loved our condo! It was our yearly yaya trip and the condo had everything we needed to make us very comfortable. Would definitely stay here again.
Tammy K.
July 2025
We enjoyed our stay at your condo. It is convenient and well supplied and comfortable. The views are fantastic. I would stay here again. Mahalo
Jerilyn D.
July 2025
Not for kids who want to yell, jump, splash, ride scootersWe ended up staying at the Residence Inn for 4 days
Glenn W.
July 2025
We really enjoyed staying at Menehune Shores - the unit & building were in great condition, it was right on the beach, and was centrally located to go sightseeing all over Maui. We enjoyed breakfast/lunch on the balcony & watching the canoes going out for the day through the rock wall. I was a little concerned about how effective the room AC units would be (since I'm used to central a/c), but we stayed completely comfortable the entire time. We came with extended family & rented 2 other units which were also nice - just pay attention to which ones have been updated. 405 was great- updated & clean. Parking spots were tight for the suburban-size vehicle we had, but fine for the more standard size car that my brother rented. We always found a spot too. Overall we thought it was a great location & value, & would definitely stay again!
Kathy C.
July 2025
Love location so close to the beach. And Christine was great to work with.
Gary D.
July 2025
Great location and owner was fantastic to deal with.
Chris N.
July 2025
Lovely and worked well for family of 3 adults.
Shawn D.
July 2025
Great condo, excellent views! There was no AC which I missed when reserving it, but that’s my fault.
Brian S.
July 2025
Great place with great views. Nice calm (fishing) pond with tons of turtles. Will definitely come back. Whale museum next door was very good also.
Sylvia R.
July 2025
My husband, preteen daughter and I really enjoyed our stay. The location makes getting around easy and everything was very clean (there was only a little toilet paper in one bathroom when we got there, so we had to go to the store soon after arriving, so grab some on the way). The beach right in front of condo is a much smaller area than I was expecting, but we found some great beaches nearby. The view from the condo is exactly as pictured and made for peaceful morning coffee time. We would stay here again.
Allison W.
July 2025
Perfect spot for a larger group. Lovely views. Great location! Pool, ancient fishing hole and beach are great! Excellent spot for kids of all ages. Owners were immediately responsive to questions or concerns. We arrived to a very air conditioned unit with beautiful Hawaiian music playing and an awesome view. The owners were gracious enough to leave us coffee and treats. The entire family said they’d come back again.We had a magical vacation here - one I know my grandchildren will remember!
Linda K.
July 2025
Aloha. Great clean unit. Property is in a great location on the beach side of the road. 1 minute from being in the condo to toes in the sand. Pool and BBQ were great amenities. Owner was very responsive when we asked her a question.
Heather S.
July 2025
Great location, with an amazing view and easy in and out!
Scott B.
July 2025
We had a great stay. We left saying we would like to return to this condo
Darrell H.
July 2025
Our place was a great location and value. Vacasa customer service were responsive.
Britt C.
July 2025
Just as listed. Had everything we needed for a nice beach vacation
Heather H.
July 2025
Can’t say enough good things about our stay at Menehune shores. Arrived at sunset and was blown away by the stunning views and the sound of the sea. The location is ideal, close to downtown Kihei for grocery, shops and easy access to all our day adventures. The grounds are so nice. We enjoyed uncrowded walks on the beach, playing shuffleboard, the pool, the rooftop grills, and loved watching the huge sea turtles sleeping on the beach in the early morning. The condo is very well thought out, kitchen well appointed, beds are comfortable, AC works well if and when you need it. We hope to be back. Mahalo!
Kim B.
July 2025
I’ve stayed here 11 years ago when my brother got married. Perfect location, close to everything, great view, gorgeous condo. We had a blast.
Amanda F.
July 2025
It was a great place with great views. However, if you’re two couples traveling together one couple is going to get the room without the great view and traffic from the street. With no AC you have to leave the windows open at night. Bring your earplugs and negotiate paying a little less with you co-travelers for the lessor room.
Doris H.
July 2025
The property was clean and as advertised, owner was easy to communicate with and the location was great for our kids.
Jordan V.
July 2025
Great location we loved the convenience.
Cory M.
July 2025
Beautiful location, decent condo. Decent supplies and furniture. Very clear instructions on usage of everything. It was both a good and bad thing to be on the 1st floor. Great to walk out to lawn and beach. Unfortunately it was very hot in June and while there was a breeze it did not cool down the bedrooms even with all windows and doors open. With everything open there was no ability for privacy
Diane P.
July 2025
We had an amazing stay! The place was absolutely perfect — clean, comfortable, and stocked with everything we needed. The location couldn’t have been better for all of our adventures, and we loved watching the sunsets each evening. Pamela’s hospitality was truly unmatched. We would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone visiting the area!
Ashlee A.
July 2025
Great condo in a good location. Easy access to the beach, close drive to restaurants and activities. Loved the beach amenities stocked in the condo. The view from the balcony was great. Top notch communications with the manager for check in. Overall, a great place for our family to stay!
Diana S.
July 2025
Great location in a quiet part of the beach. The yard was perfect for the kids to chill and play. The only issue with the location is the beach itself. It is not exactly ideal or picturesque once the winds kick up. Beaches that are more kids friendly for swimming are about 10 minutes down the road. Other than that, great trip
Josh G.
July 2025
Great property! Everyone was so nice, the property was clean and the owners are super friendly and accommodating
Chantelle S.
July 2025
The condo was clean and as advertised! Updated amenities and the owners were very responsive. Great location, especially for kids swimming. We will be back!
Jordan V.
July 2025
Picture perfect stay pool on beach clean spacious lovely
Gary C.
July 2025
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this beautiful condo! It was so clean and welcoming, with plenty of towels, beach chairs and a fully functioning kitchen. Our kids loved playing on the beach, which was just steps from the room. We were sad to leave, but hope to be back to stay again someday!
Laura F.
July 2025
So happy we picked this location. So many items available for us to use in the unit. Only missing thing would be AC so we could keep the windows shut and the bird song out each morning. But it was clean, comfortable and safe. Never a worry. That n you so much.
Jennifer K.
July 2025
I took my wife to Hawaii for her birthday and stayed here during our trip. The view from the condo is incredible, a great place to watch the sunset over maui. The condo also had beach chairs, boogie boards, coolers, a beach mat and umbrella available for our use. . It is also well located in Kihei. Very close to grocery stores, shops, resturants. There is also 2 very nice beaches located steps away from the ground level of the condo complex. I would 100% stay here again.
Justin C.
July 2025
Our condo was relaxing and right next to Kalepolepo Beach Park, a beach with a protected swimming area that is ideal for young children. We had a wonderful time, and the supplied beach equipment (chairs, toys, snorkeling gear) was extremely helpful. I hope to come back in the future.
James C.
July 2025