The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Staying at Menehune Shores feels quintessentially oceanfront: you’re steps from the sand with sweeping lanai views of Maalaea Bay, nightly sunsets, and in-season whale sightings. A unique highlight is the historic rock fishpond right out front, which creates a shallow, protected lagoon that’s ideal for kids and calmer swims; sea turtles regularly rest on the rocks here. Guests love the quiet, well-kept grounds, heated pool (heater occasionally down), big grassy lawn, shuffleboard, and the panoramic rooftop with BBQs and a convivial sunset vibe. The North Kihei location is central for exploring Maui (Wailea, Haleakalā, Road to Hana, airport), yet feels laid back and uncrowded.
Condos vary by owner, but the overall theme is clean, comfortable, and well-equipped. Many units are updated and thoughtfully stocked with beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, snorkel sets), full kitchens, and in‑unit laundry; hosts and managers are frequently praised as responsive and accommodating. Some units have efficient mini‑split A/C in bedrooms/living areas, while others rely on trade winds, ceiling fans, and cross‑breezes; most guests report sleeping comfortably with windows open. Nice pluses: easy beach access, a quick walk to Kalepolepo Beach Park and the Humpback Whale Sanctuary, rooftop grilling, and an onsite Indian restaurant (Monsoon) that many enjoy.
Good to know: this is an older, well‑maintained complex, and individual units differ in décor and features—read the specific listing for A/C coverage, shade on the lanai, and recent updates. Afternoons can be windy, and the bay water here is often shallow and can look murkier than the postcard‑blue beaches; for clearer snorkeling or bigger waves, plan short drives to Wailea/Kapalua. Common nits mentioned across reviews include tight parking stalls and occasional road noise in end units, sporadic pool heater outages or maintenance closures (no hot tub), limited shade at the pool/roof, and the rare cleanliness or pest issue that’s typically addressed when reported. Overall sentiment is strongly positive: guests highlight the views, turtle encounters, central convenience, and family‑friendly setting—and many say they’d happily return.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
We enjoyed our stay in north Kīhei. The condo was very clean and had all the necessities we needed during our stay. The bed was very comfortable!!! The view of the ocean from the deck was spectacular! We would definitely stay here again!!
Lori K.
April 2026
Great location! The condo is right on the beach, with easy access. A wonderful pool if you prefer and super fun shuffle board! The room was perfect! It had everything we needed. The owners were super easy to work with and communicated quickly!
Janet D.
April 2026
Great stay at Menehune 505! The condo is very well maintained, clean, and perfect for families. The kitchen is fully stocked, making it easy to cook meals at home. We loved having beach gear (chairs, umbrella, cooler), plus plenty of kids’ games and sand toys for our daily outings.There’s a beach area directly south of the property (a “fish pond”) that’s ideal for small children. The property also offers two separate grilling areas with picnic tables, which are great for larger group outdoor meals.Each bedroom has its own AC unit, which was a big plus, and the rooftop deck is great for sunsets. The pool was clean and inviting. (note: there is no hot tub). Jim was an excellent host—very communicative and helpful, especially during the recent Maui flooding.Highly recommend!
Jody J.
April 2026
Great clean place to stay.
Gary M.
April 2026
Nice, clean unit with amazing views of the ocean
Bob M.
April 2026
Beautiful space, comfortable beds, great location, awesome view. Easy beach access for long walks, turtles in the morning, local dining and activity recs from our awesome host, such a great vacation for our family of four. Mahalo!
Michelle H.
April 2026
We enjoyed this room tremendously. It was nicely updated and the view was spectacular. Very clean and everything was top notched. Kristin was great to work with.
Katie J.
April 2026
pool pump was broken. Took a long time to get it fixed
Rick C.
April 2026
Amazing view, clean rooms, Nice location.
Gerald F.
April 2026
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay! The condo is beautifully decorated and incredibly comfortable with high-end furnishings. And Helen is an amazing host. We had a minor challenge at check-in, but Helen responded immediately and went above and beyond, turning it into a complete non-issue. We'd love to return!
Brian R.
April 2026
Great Area, on the beach close to Kīhei. Parking was good, you feel safe. Clean condo and easy to talk to the host.Home away from home! Very relaxing! Second time we have stayed here.
Cathy W.
April 2026
Menehune Shores in North Kihei is the perfect location for a Maui vacation. The Ancient Hawaiian Fishpond and adjacent beaches are great places to relax and explore with family. We loved daily walks collecting shells and seeing sea turtles. This ground floor condo is set up nicely with two bedrooms in addition to the living area and lanai all being oceanfront. We enjoyed sitting on the lanai eating breakfast, relaxing, and viewing the sunset. The weather was perfect for opening the windows and doors allowing the breeze and sounds of ocean waves to flow through the space. Our host honestly responded to our concerns about the recent Kona Low and how it impacted the island and condo. We kept a close eye on up-to-date progress and were impressed by the quick clean up process by the local municipalities. We did not reschedule, and were very pleased to be able to do everything on our itinerary, including snorkeling, surfing, and exploring the road to Hana.
Dee K.
April 2026
This rental exceeded ALL expectations! First of all, the views are exceptional, absolutely beautiful, breathtaking of the West Maui Mountains AND from the other side of the unit a spectacular view of Haleakala. Every morning I went on a long walk on the beach which is just steps away from the unit. On each morning walk I was blessed to discover multiple green sea turtles resting on the beach and even got to witness a few of them returning to the waterjust magical! There is also a roof top common area with grills and picnic tables with more mind-blowing views of the island of Maui. The sunsets are fabulous from the lanai of the unit and from the 7th floor roof top. It is in a great location as it is close to grocery stores, restaurants and shopping. I cannot say enough wonderful things about this unit in Menehune Shores. We will definitely return and we will let all of our friends and family know about this fantastic place to stay.
Connie G.
April 2026
Beautiful place!! The view was amazing, the property was lovely. The only thing is that the listing said there was a hot tub and there is no hot tub on the property. The pool is heated(ish) but there is not a hot tub. Otherwise, lovely place to stay!
Lauren F.
April 2026
Everything was perfect and the condo was very well equipped with everything we could need for a two week visit!
Tree Line V.
April 2026
Wonderful hosts - very responsive, helpful and friendly. The unit was exactly as described - very spacious, clean and adorably decorated (we loved the sea turtle motif!). We very much appreciated use of the beach chairs and towels. The unit is well located - lots of good options for food and activities. Highly recommend!
Dorrie M.
April 2026
This place is fabulous! Very clean, spacious, centrally located to everything. But the best part is the bed, so comfy. Watching the sunset and moon come down eat day was a highlight. They thought of everything and the place was so well stocked (spices, Brita, pots, pans, flashlights, beach chairs, umbrella, so much more). We have stayed at multiple places in Maui and this was the best.
Chris M.
April 2026
Stop looking! This amazing codo is the perfect spot for your vacation! Our family visited for Spring Break 2026. The condo is pristine - freshly renovated with top of the line finishes and appliances. A great location in Kihei with direct access to the beach, and central to other activities. Fully stocked with everything you need for the kitchen, coffee, and enjoying the beach (chairs, umbrellas, boogie boards). Bed and bath accomodations are top notch. Comfortable, big beds and high quality linens. The hosts also take it to the next level! Responsive, communicative, and offered great recommendations for all of our interests. If I could give a 10 star review, I would. We loved every minute of our stay - highly recommend!
Linda B.
April 2026
Due to the recent Kona storm we were unable to stay as planned, but the management company was amazing with their communication after the storm and ensuring we found somewhere to stay as the condo was inaccessible due to the flooding. In such a challenging time for the community, we appreciate the prompt response. I look forward to planning another visit in a few years and we’ll definitely book the same condo. Thank you!
Angela S.
April 2026
Awesome location. Incredible property. Well appointed condo. Comfortable, spacious, plenty of kitchenware for cooking in. Quiet. Very kid-friendly. Centrally located and easy to get to both west and south beaches. Nice wading spot right off the property. Good beach walks. Host was wonderful to work with. Strong recommendation!
Paul C.
April 2026
Due to inclement weather we did not get much use of the pool, or any thing else outside
Debbie C.
April 2026
The electricity went out right after our arrival and stayed out for 48 hours. We could not get out of the condo parking lot for 3 days. Road blocked most of the next 5 days.We left a day early because of Another Kona coming in. The owner told us he was going to give us 1/2 of our money back. I did not ask he volunteered. Then he refunded us for the day we left and decided not to refund the 1/2 of our price. Don’t volunteer to refund 1/2 and then change your mind 4 days later. I also want to say that he didn’t contact us at all during the storm until I asked him to text me because we didn’t have WiFi either and he responded rudely with a reprimand, like I knew the owner was on the other end and I had his number…no I didn’t and wasn’t even thinking in that direction with no electricity, WiFi, and blocked transportation.He should have been so proud that we kept that red mud out of the condo! Some condos looked tracked into!
Dana P.
April 2026
This was our second stay at the lovely property, Maui Moon. You will not find a better view! Menehune Shores is so well maintained, with a location that works well for us. This particular unit has everything one would need, is decorated nicely and the owner could not be easier to work with. We are hoping to return to the beautiful island of Maui. The horrific Knoa Low didn’t keep us away!
Diane H.
April 2026
Good experience, the property is a little dated and coffee service could have been better, it looked like somebodies leftover coffee package
tiruvilvamalai s.
April 2026
Very nice CleanAs advertised
john t.
April 2026
The beach view was fantastic. We really appreciated the proximity of the unit to the beach. The unit was very clean. The A/C unit malfunctioned which caused power outage, and subsequent A/C outage. However, host was pretty responsive in communications. We weathered the Kona storms during our stay, it was not hot and the A/C was not a huge disruption, all things considered.
Tina K.
March 2026
The condo is amazing - inside and out! The decor is gorgeous, just as you see in the pictures. There was every thing you need for your stay in every respect - more things in the kitchen then I have at home! Host was very responsive and helpful! Check in was easy. The community at this complex was warm and welcoming. Highly recommend.
Anne P.
March 2026
We had unfortunate timing with arriving during and right after the second Kona storm so the water and beach were unusable but we still had a fabulous time. The location was perfect for getting around the island and to all our activities and great beaches, we saw so many whales in the ocean off the porch, we were able to walk the beach and saw tons of basking turtles. Host was amazing and easy to communicate with and the house was fully stocked with all beach things and supplies we needed for a family of 7. Highly recommend!
Anne Claire H.
March 2026
room had a great location but weather prevent full usage of the great property and electrical outages dampened the stay
Kelsey B.
March 2026
The new beach chairs and boogie boards were a great addition. The view from the condo is fabulous! There are items in the condo that should be updated.
Diane M.
March 2026
Key pad to enter the condo is very easy to use. Kitchen is well stocked. Excellent location. Ground floor is perfect for our family member using a walker. Fish pond is perfect for playing in the water without waves to knock children or seniors over. Turtles haul out at the fishpond which is awesome. Complex has bbq’s that are extremely clean and in perfect working condition.I found the guest bed to be very hard. That’s just my opinion, I sleep on a soft bed at home. Don’t know about the primary bedroom’s bed.
Donna B.
March 2026
The room had everything we needed pots pans seasoning silverware plates, utensils anything I needed it was there. ( one thing it didn’t have or I couldn’t find it was a pizza cutter) The place was so clean and had everything we needed for a day on the beach. Second floor was very handy the staff was very helpful.Thank you for letting us stay in your home!Marlene
Marlene R.
March 2026
We had the best experience with this VBRO rental. From start to finish, Helen and Mark were amazing! They sent us great ideas of places to eat and things to see! The luau they recommended was so fun!The unit is updated, very clean and well stocked with everything needed for a great vacation getaway. Beds were super comfortable along with the bedding!We really enjoyed the area. Great local restaurants and shops and centrally located if you want to explore the island. Our last 4 days were during the Kona flood and unfortunately we were without electricity and stranded for 48 hours at the rental. Helen and Mark reached out to us to make sure that we were safe and secure during our last few days in Kihei and went above and beyond to accommodate us at check out. We definitely recommend Kihei Coop!!
Jann C.
March 2026
As lovely as always. Very clean place, well stocked kitchen, beautiful view, and quiet. The host is always super responsive as well. Can't ask for more!
Christina K.
March 2026
Everything was absolutely perfect! Steps to the pool. And not far from the beach.
Karen M.
March 2026
This condo was the most well organized and stocked condo I have stayed in at Menehune Shores. The kitchen appliances and utensils were well stocked, there were plenty of towels and linens were clean and comfortable, and the air conditioning worked perfectly (individual for each room). There were even beach chairs and boogie boards available. We return for work once a year and always stay at this complex. This unit will definitely be on the list of preferred units.
Alison R.
March 2026
We loved our stay. Our host Sande was very accommodating and everyone was so pleasant. We will stay there again in the future.
Randall L.
March 2026
loved the location!
Montana R.
March 2026
Great view! We watched whales from the room every day we were there. Wow! Lots of turtles in the cove area directly in front of the room. Walkable beach was a nice treat in the mornings. Condo is nicely updated and we greatly appreciated the AC in the bedroom for nighttime but really only needed it about twice. Good location.
Amanda A.
March 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
The three of us arrived at about 8:30 pm after shopping for breakfast items on the way from the airport. Numeric code worked well for us, with many entrances and exits. Beautiful view of sunsets from the back patio. Coffee maker was brand new! Great step by step instructions for the tv. Ice maker didn’t work and rental company said they’d send someone over but we said no need as we picked up ice from the store. Two nice coolers for day trips. We would rent here again. Air conditioners for bedrooms and living room allowed us to select a comfortable temperature for each of us!
Robert W.
March 2026
Absolutely beautiful place to stay. Enjoyed it very much. Highly recommend it.
Donna W.
March 2026
We had a great view of whales spouting from our balcony.
SUSAN
March 2026
Lovely setting, view of beautiful gardens and ocean. Enjoyed magnificent sunsets. Very well equipped.
Linda B.
March 2026
Awesome stay with beautiful views, comfortable and well furnished condo! Thank You for a beautiful Hawaiian vacation in Kihei!
Michele H.
March 2026
Absolutely as pictured and as described. I wish we could have stayed longer. Hope to come back soon! The condo had everything and more, and that rooftop area was beautiful.
Karen S.
March 2026
Well appointed, beautiful views!
Debbie R.
March 2026
Wow! The Maui Moon was absolutely incredible. Pamela has thought of everything. As if the view wasn’t worth it all, the kitchen and laundry was perfect for our 2 week stay. The kitchen was wonderful to keep all of our drinks, leftovers, snacks, and to make breakfast. The laundry came in handy to do a couple loads mid way through our trip (pods were there for us to use). We couldn’t get enough of the balcony (she even had binoculars!) to watch for whales, have our morning coffee, drinks at night, etc. We spent most all of our time out there when we weren’t out exploring or at the pool. Bed was comfy and the bathroom was well stocked and perfect! We will DEFINITELY make it back to the Maui Moon again!
Andrea S.
March 2026
All good. Loved walking right out from patio to beach.
judy s.
March 2026
Beautiful condo. Had everything you need. Great view. comfortable bed.
Don E.
March 2026
Had a great time. The AC units in each room were a huge plus. The unit also came with 4 beach chairs which was really convenient. 10/10.
Josef K.
March 2026