The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Sugar Beach Resort consistently earns praise for its unbeatable beachfront setting and central, low‑key North Kihei location. Guests love stepping straight onto a long, uncrowded stretch of sand, lingering over sunrise coffee and sunset cocktails on the lanai, and watching outrigger canoes, turtles, and seasonal whales. The vibe is peaceful and family‑friendly, with well‑kept grounds, a pool, hot tub, lawn loungers facing the ocean, clean BBQs, outdoor rinses, and handy on‑site extras like an activity/concierge desk, gear rental, a casual sandwich bar, and even a massage clinic. A bakery, small farmers market, shave ice, and an ABC store are an easy beach walk away, and free/covered parking makes airport runs and day trips to Wailea, Lahaina, Haleakalā, and Upcountry simple.
Most condos are individually owned and many are updated, very clean, and thoughtfully stocked. Travelers frequently note well‑equipped kitchens, in‑unit washer/dryers, strong A/C in many units, comfortable beds, and a trove of beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, boogie boards, snorkels). Hosts are often responsive and proactive with arrival info and local tips, and check‑in is typically smooth.
Common trade‑offs to know: the complex is older and quality varies by unit/manager; a minority of reviews mention dated decor or housekeeping misses, so choose a recently refreshed condo when possible. North Kihei is famously breezy—expect windy afternoons—and Sugar Beach’s fine sand/mud flats can make near‑shore water look brown or choppy at times; it’s fantastic for long walks but not Maui’s best spot for snorkeling or consistently calm swimming (many guests drive south for that). Some units get light road or wind noise, a few report occasional fishy odors from the nearby pond/harbor when the wind shifts, and the original floorplan means small bathrooms and, in some units, bedroom access through the bath. Dining is limited within walking distance beyond the on‑site deli and a few nearby spots, so a car is recommended. If you’re seeking a quiet, centrally located, true‑beachfront condo with great value and views, Sugar Beach fits beautifully; if you want resort glitz, multiple restaurants on site, and crystal‑clear water at your doorstep every day, look elsewhere.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
Great place!
Nyela E.
July 2026
Greg is a super helpful host. We loved our stay at Sugar Beach. We explored the whole island and loved its central location! We stayed at the end of June in 2026 and had beautiful weather. We met lots of wonderful people and had some amazing adventures. Sad to say I highly recommend this place because it will probably be tougher to book next time if we are able to swing another trip. The beach right out front of the condo is long and perfect for walking on. Loved sitting on the lanai in the mornings with coffee watching the waves and canoes. We feel totally blessed. This trip was truly special. The bed was comfortable, the TV stayed off (on purpose), the pool and hot tub were a great way to unwind at night after the sun set. We made use of the in unit washer and dryer. And as a side note Gretchen at Dina’s Sandwitch shop found on the resort property makes terrific drinks if that’s something you are looking for.
stacey b.
July 2026
Absolutely loved our 2 weeks here. Definitely plan to return for future vacations.
Scotty E.
July 2026
A step away to the pool & the beach from our place! Well maintained with lots of little helpful additions.
Amy W.
July 2026
I had such a wonderful time staying in this condo. It was very homey and I felt very comfortable from the first day. It was nice having all the amenities right there and everything was very clean and well maintained. I will definitely be staying here again!
Ethan C.
June 2026
Beautiful view and a perfect stay for our family of four. We will definitely be back. The Ali'i Resorts team was great with communication and flexible with our check in and check out times. The condo was comfortable and spacious.
Melissa I.
June 2026
Incredible view of both the water and Haleakala. Very close to Kihei. Large, spacious condo. Nice to be able to spread out. Check in was super easy.
Michael B.
June 2026
We stayed for a week with my sister and kids.It feels like home.Nice kitchen and beach front view and swimming pool access to all of us.
quenny w.
June 2026
Gorgeous views!Perfect location for everything!Condo was stocked with everything we could possibly need! Beach chairs, umbrella, towels, and even snorkeling equipment!Clean Easy access to the beach for sunrise and sunset walksGreat communication with the host Walked to Sugar Beach Bake Shop twice for their famous Malasadas!!! I would highly recommend this unit! It was perfect for me and my husband’s first trip to Hawaii!
Janet B.
June 2026
Really nice. Would stay again
David M.
June 2026
Great property, loved the lanai for morning coffee! Property manager was very responsive.
Christina M.
June 2026
We loved staying at this property:) Everything was as advertised and Kevin was super responsive to any questions I had. The grounds were beautiful and had everything we needed. We'll be back!
Dawn M.
June 2026
The property was exactly as described. We enjoyed breakfast on the lani with beautiful beachfront views. Collin and Kevin were easy to communicate with and the condo had everything we needed and more, from beach chairs and snorkel gear to coffee and plenty of Tupperware to bring the best local snacks down by the pool to enjoy all day long! The location was perfect if you want to be able to walk along the amazing sand sugar beach and be close to town! We loved that it wasn't super touristy but we were able to head to all the fun spots when we wanted! We will definitely be saving Collin and Kevin's place to book next time we are back!
Joe S.
June 2026
I would not recommend this rental until the owner does significant mold remediation. There is black mold growing in the shower, in the sofa bed mattress and there is bubbling and peeling in paint in various places throughout the unit. There was also a lot of dust build up around the unit and the bathroom vents were so caked with dust that chunks would come off when we showered. The refrigerator had broken shelves. It’s unfortunate that this unit has these issues because the location is great. It’s been poorly maintained.
Samantha W.
June 2026
You can't beat the view. Sitting on the lanai having your morning coffee watching the waves crash on the beach below was unbeatable. A five minute walk down the beach is a great little bakery and farmers market for freshly baked pastries and local fruit. We would definitely stay there again.
Peter S.
June 2026
The unit was very clean and all appliances were in good working order. The view was amazing from the deck.
Eric W.
June 2026
Beautiful view from the balcony right on the beach!. Easy driving access to everything we wanted to see.
Barb I.
June 2026
The room and communication were amazing! Thank you for such a wonderful week!!
Deric M.
June 2026
Amazing trip! Very clean and excellent location! Host responded quickly to all messages. We will definitely stay here again!
Barbie D.
June 2026
We stayed at this property once before and decided to return. It was expensive, but we enjoyed it. Good quality, cleanliness, functionality in the unit. Can’t beat the view or access to the beach. Parking was easy. We had very noisy neighbors at one point, and called the office. Whatever intervention they had worked well and quickly. No noise after that. Much appreciated. Kitchen and lanai are great. Things to improve: bedroom door didn’t close easily - needs to be planed. Toilet is really tiny! Lots of street and wind noise in bedroom (ok with earplugs).
David S.
June 2026
This is an amazing condo and has all the accommodations you can imagine. Central location. Waking up to the beautiful ocean right outside your condo, nothing can be better!!
Katie D.
June 2026
The condo had a great Ocean view and Pool with Hot Tub to enjoy after the days activities
M C.
June 2026
This is a beautiful second floor property with the beach right off of the patio. Perfect for enjoying a cup of coffee in the morning and a glass of wine in the evening. The condo is close to the elevator but down a little hallway which made it quiet and convenient. With a rental car it is close to the airport and shopping while also being on a very peaceful stretch of the beach. It is also about 10 minutes from Maalaea Harbor where a lot of the snorkeling and cruise tours depart. The pool and hot tub were also a great alternative to swimming in the ocean. The host communication was excellent and I will stay here again, hopefully soon. Relaxing in Maui was so good for my soul.
Tamra R.
June 2026
The condo was cozy and decorated nicely. Had everything we needed in the kitchen, which made meal prep easy. Property was nice, clean and quite. It was also just a 20 minute drive from the restaurants in Kihei, as well as the airport. Great location for any day adventures. The views were also fantastic and the beach was nice to walk on day or night. Quick tip...take the beach down to Sugar Beach Bake Shop in the morning, you won't be disappointed! Would highly recommend this condo!!!
Andrew T.
June 2026
I highly recommend this beautiful property! I had a wonderful stay and really enjoyed how close this property is to the beach, the garden, and the pool. Thanks again and I’ll see you next time!
Kelly C.
June 2026
Very close to the beach. Less crowded area made it an excellent place to relax. Had all the amenities to make our stay pleasant.
Kaye B.
June 2026
This is a great place to stay. The view is amazing. Had everything we needed. The pool area is great. Good central location on the west side of Maui.
Richard T.
June 2026
Perfect view, great location, everything was wonderful!
Skyler M.
June 2026
This was our 2nd stay here. Everything is amazing.
Scott L.
June 2026
View was incredible and only a few steps from the beach. Joan was responsive and helpful. Highly recommend
Ben W.
June 2026
Kristi was so helpful with any questions I had about my stay and I would def return to this unit PH1 at Sugar Beach Resort. Location was so convenient and close to every where I wanted to go. View is incredible and the unit was stocked with so many extras for the beach and cooking. Highly recommend this place for anyone who wishes to come to Maui. Truly Heaven on Earth ! 🥰
Patty T.
June 2026
Has everything you need and you cannot beat the location. Everything works, slept great, would definitely book again
Michelle S.
June 2026
Great communication with host. Nice supply of umbrellas, beach chairs and coolers
chino M.
June 2026
The unit was so clean and had everything we needed. The beach towels and beach gear (chairs, umbrella, etc) was great. The kitchen was well stocked so we could make some meals at home. The unit was in a great central location allowing us to drive all over the island.
Makenzie W.
June 2026
These owners were the absolute BEST hosts!! Lots of communication, including the day of arrival and throughout our trip. The hosts literally bent over backwards to help us out with the condo dates when we had an issue with our airline. Then, when we arrived there was a beautiful welcome basket with much needed treats after a long travel day and we had arrived late at night! The condo is so comfortable and has everything you could want for an amazing vacation. The kitchen has all the things you need to cook everyday if you like. The bed is huge and very comfortable, as well as the bathroom which is nicely updated and modern. We also stayed in this unit last year and we loved it so much we came back! The view is so incredible and we would recommend these hosts and this unit 110% to everyone. Mahalo for a wonderful stay!!
A S.
June 2026
We really enjoy staying here at Sugar Beach!! This condo is always perfect in every way! We have stayed here multiple times and it is always a great experience. Would highly recommend this condo!!
Lela N.
June 2026
Amazing views from the kitchen and balcony. Incredible grill area located near the beach and pool.
Tennessee_ E.
June 2026
Our family really enjoyed our stay at the condo. There were a few minor things that could use a little TLC but overall it was great! PROS: location, magical balcony, one bedroom had a very nice firm matress, futon-sofa, warm pool, easy checking & parking. CONS: one closet blanket, sofa pillow & a towel had stains, two oven burners were not working, boogie board had 4 holes so wasn't very useful to float. Appreciate having WD-40 & Raid Insect indoor spray, always come in handy at any rentals. Mahalo!
Natalya G.
June 2026
Clean, modern, beautiful views great location!
Mindy S.
June 2026
I rented the room for the ocean view primarily and was not disappointed. Just absolutely gorgeous walking out of the bedroom to have an unobstructed view of the ocean. Any complaints I have make me sound like a pampered prince. Could have been a little cleaner, would have preferred 2ply toilet paper and liquid soap, and time to replace a few of the items like knives and the cooler. That said I’d definitely stay here again.
Andrew R.
June 2026
Very desirable place to spend time
Dave A.
June 2026
Fully equipped for all your needs. Just steps away from a nice pool and beach. Only minutes from airport and shopping. It may be a little dated but very clean and a great value for the price.
Stephen M.
June 2026
Check in was listed as 3pm. Could not access my room until 4pm. The unit had a scheduled power outage all day and I was not notified. No apologies from the owner.
Bill S.
June 2026
A perfect location. Very well appointed. Had the most relaxing time.
Michelle B.
June 2026
Communication was excellent. The priperty had all of the amenities. Great location. Million dollar view.
Vincent C.
June 2026
Absolutely loved my stay! The location is perfect. It was so close to fantastic spots to eat and local gems, with a must-try recommendation: Sugar Beach Bake Shop (don’t miss it! The Masalada and the Cinnamon Roll **drool). The condo had everything I could possibly need, from all the household essentials to a wonderfully refreshing AC. There were beach towels and beach chairs. They didnt miss a beat. Oh, and that ocean view with the sandy beach that went for miles. It was truly surreal. This VRBO made my trip unforgettable. I can’t wait to come back.
Crystal S.
June 2026
Very clean, well supplied. They had everything including large bottle of shampoo & conditioner. Only thing missing was shower soap!
Kim S.
June 2026
Great room with a awesome view
Nate B.
June 2026