The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Sugar Beach Resort consistently earns praise for its unbeatable beachfront setting and central, low‑key North Kihei location. Guests love stepping straight onto a long, uncrowded stretch of sand, lingering over sunrise coffee and sunset cocktails on the lanai, and watching outrigger canoes, turtles, and seasonal whales. The vibe is peaceful and family‑friendly, with well‑kept grounds, a pool, hot tub, lawn loungers facing the ocean, clean BBQs, outdoor rinses, and handy on‑site extras like an activity/concierge desk, gear rental, a casual sandwich bar, and even a massage clinic. A bakery, small farmers market, shave ice, and an ABC store are an easy beach walk away, and free/covered parking makes airport runs and day trips to Wailea, Lahaina, Haleakalā, and Upcountry simple.
Most condos are individually owned and many are updated, very clean, and thoughtfully stocked. Travelers frequently note well‑equipped kitchens, in‑unit washer/dryers, strong A/C in many units, comfortable beds, and a trove of beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, boogie boards, snorkels). Hosts are often responsive and proactive with arrival info and local tips, and check‑in is typically smooth.
Common trade‑offs to know: the complex is older and quality varies by unit/manager; a minority of reviews mention dated decor or housekeeping misses, so choose a recently refreshed condo when possible. North Kihei is famously breezy—expect windy afternoons—and Sugar Beach’s fine sand/mud flats can make near‑shore water look brown or choppy at times; it’s fantastic for long walks but not Maui’s best spot for snorkeling or consistently calm swimming (many guests drive south for that). Some units get light road or wind noise, a few report occasional fishy odors from the nearby pond/harbor when the wind shifts, and the original floorplan means small bathrooms and, in some units, bedroom access through the bath. Dining is limited within walking distance beyond the on‑site deli and a few nearby spots, so a car is recommended. If you’re seeking a quiet, centrally located, true‑beachfront condo with great value and views, Sugar Beach fits beautifully; if you want resort glitz, multiple restaurants on site, and crystal‑clear water at your doorstep every day, look elsewhere.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
Our 1st trip to Hawaii and it was perfect, Thanks to the beautiful penthouse property we were fortunate enough to stay at. The view captivated us instantly. It’s paradise. It made it very difficult to leave and explore Maui with such a gorgeous view..morning, noon, and night. The unit is lined with mirrors on one side which make the room look twice as big and beautiful. The kitchen is spacious and clean with everything you need. There are bbqs downstairs which we used a lot. Elevators are close and quick. The beach, footsteps away. Stretched as far as you could see in either direction. We were happy to see the beach showers, much needed. The pool was refreshing and clean, a relaxing reprieve from the warm ocean waters, waves and sand. The hot tub is nice and big. Not as inviting after a good sunburn. The grounds are kept clean, lush and green with a little koi pond to say aloha. Mike and Brenda were beyond amazing. They really made us feel at home and welcomed. Their hospitality and kindness made this trip feel blessed and their beautiful penthouse condo made this trip unforgettable. We will surely be back.
Melissa F.
September 2025
Everything was simply amazing and so perfect! The condo was beautiful with an amazing view and was a great location for an HQ for all of our adventures. The sandwich shop downstairs was very convenient - and a super cute dive bar to boot! I could not have been more pleased with our stay and would absolutely stay here again!
Alison E.
September 2025
We had a wonderful stay! Condo was well equipped and location is so convenient.
Francine F.
September 2025
My husband and I spent 5 days in Doreen's condo on Sugar Beach. We would highly recommend this unit to anyone visiting Maui. Spotless, fully stocked and the MOST comfortable bed! But the view from the lanai is the star! We could have spent the whole trip on the lanai looking at the amazing view of the ocean and listening to the waves! Perfect location in Kihei central to all the sites on the island. Thank you again Doreen!
MARY KAY A.
September 2025
Clean room and property; excellent beach view; very relaxing; lots of amenities; friendly and accessible manager. Highly recommend. Would stay there again.
Brian L.
September 2025
Overall excellent location
kellie e.
September 2025
This is the second time we’ve stayed in Doug’s unit and absolutely loved it! The unit is beautifully decorated and very comfortable. The view from the lanai is wonderful and we spent most mornings and evenings out there. The sunsets are gorgeous! Doug is always very responsive and so easy to work with. Management is also helpful. We requested a fan after our first night and they delivered it the same day. We'll definitely stay here again next time we visit Maui.
Karen B.
September 2025
Wonderful vacation with my daughter!!
bradley m.
September 2025
I really wanted to give this stay 5 stars, but unfortunately, I can’t. The check-in process was smooth, but once we got inside, we noticed the floors were extremely dirty—after just five minutes of walking around, our socks were covered in grime. The AC wasn’t strong enough to cool the bedroom, making it uncomfortably warm at night. The Wi-Fi and cable kept cutting out, which wasn’t a huge issue since we were out most of the time, but still worth mentioning.On the bright side, the view from the balcony was absolutely stunning, and the location couldn’t be better—right on the beach. They also provide chairs and snorkel gear, which was a nice touch. I genuinely hoped to leave a higher rating, but the cleanliness and comfort issues made that difficult.
Beth S.
September 2025
The stay was great. It had an amazing view and the condo was very neat when it was given to us
sandeep m.
September 2025
This corner unit condo was fabulous. It was very close to the pool and had the greatest view. I loved that the unit had AC as we are from the Midwest and get hot easily! My only suggestion would be to upgrade the hairdryer in the unit. There were 3 in the drawer. One didn’t turn on, the other smelled like it was going to catch on fire, and the third looked like it was from 1984. All other amenities were great. I appreciated the few k-cups of coffee and we made great use on the washer and dryer. I would stay there again
Nicole H.
September 2025
This condo has everything you need. It sets the bar for what a rental should be. As others have said all you need to bring is your clothes and sunblock. The host provides the rest!This is the most well appointed and clean property we have stayed in. The kitchen has all appliances you need, all the spices, baking, entertaining and storage dishes needed. The washer and dryer in the condo is a nice convenience too. The bed is comfortable.The Beach equipment is all in good working condition, pool noodles, chairs, umbrella, mats and coolers.The host is great at communication and even provided some great tips based on our interests. The property is well represented in the photos and the location is great, right on the beach, quick access to anywhere on the island and the property grounds and pool are well maintained.
Neil B.
September 2025
This host has thought of everything! We enjoyed our stay and loved sitting in the lanai overlooking the ocean! Would definitely stay again.
September 2025
Great experience on Maui good location nice and quiet beautiful view
Mark A.
September 2025
This was our first visit to Maui. We loved this condo. You can't beat the view and only steps from the beach. We definitely recommend this property and hope to return sometime in the not too distant future.
Charles B.
September 2025
Property was as advertised. Beautiful view from the lanai with the sound of the ocean waves serenading us each day. Host was quick to respond to any questions we had.
Tricia D.
September 2025
Aloha, we loved staying in your condo. It is so beautifully decorated with the Hawaiian culture and the ocean views are breathtaking especially in the evening on the lanai with the moon and stars over the ocean. Mahalo, Malia
Malia N.
September 2025
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Completely wonderful from start to finish.
Karen W.
September 2025
We enjoyed our stay in Sugar Beach! The location is perfect and the beach is stunning! We will have to visit again sometime soon!
Debbie G.
September 2025
We enjoyed are stay at Sugar Beach Resort. The owner, Kevin, was great at communicating with us about the Penthouse and provided all the information we needed. Would highly recommend this property.
Kathryn D.
September 2025
Beautiful spot in a great location. Loved the sandwich shop/bar on the property! Condo was clean, modern, and had everything you need for a comfortable stay!
Joanna M.
September 2025
The unit was clean, well maintained and has everything we needed. Just steps away from both the pool and beach! There is also a sandwich shop located in the complex that was excellent.
Susan S.
September 2025
The unit it self was nice, could use a new bed. location was great. The only problem was construction going on all day on the units next door. The noise was so loud in the room we had to leave for the day. Pretty disappointed for the money we spent. Feel like we should be reimbursed for the stay.
daryl m.
August 2025
We had a fantastic time in PH20 at the Sugar Beach Resort. Mike left us goodies and drinks for our arrival and also left us Starbucks coffee gift cards when we left. The condo had everything we needed. Loved hearing the ocean waves and watching the sunrise every day and night. Watching the Kihei Canoe Club every morning was a plus. Our early morning walks on Sugar Beach was fantastic. We will definitely stay at Sugar Beach Resort PH20 again.
Tammy J.
August 2025
Unit was awesome, great decor. Very well stocked with everything you need. Great location. This unit was much nicer than others we stayed at on this property.
daryl m.
August 2025
Loved the location and the amazing view
Jody E.
August 2025
Everything was perfect just one glitch with the code not working.
Tonya M.
August 2025
Great access to pool and the beach. Upscale furnishing. Bed very comfortable. Supplied with everything you need
Marjorie M.
August 2025
Nice and clean, good to stay for a some time
Sergey Z.
August 2025
Great stay and very responsive host. The view is beautiful and the property is as described. Would definitely stay there again.
Anastasia B.
August 2025
Great location! Amazing view! Had a wonderful stay! Would definitely stay here again. The view from the balcony says it all!
Adrian B.
August 2025
Great view from the patio. Central location.
Shauni S.
August 2025
![Sugar Beach Resort 628]()
Our stay was outstanding! This has been our third time to Maui but condo was our favorite out of all of our stays. The view is amazing! See pictures below. This condo has everything you would need for a stay. We went to Costco right after arrival stocked up and really didn’t have to go back to a supermarket. FYI- coffee maker is the regular not a Keurig so don’t buy pods. There were ample kitchen supplies including dishes, glasses and utensils! We didn’t have to buy toilet paper as we usually do and they ever has shampoo and shower gel. We used our own but that is really thoughtful. Everything work well and was in good condition. We used dish wash, stove, frig/freezer, washer and drier had no problems!The resort itself is well ran and they keep the grounds and amenities to a high standard. The location was perfect. We love this area because it’s on Sugar Beach and it’s pretty easy to get to everything we wanted to do within 30 minutes.This resort has a really awesome sandwich shop Dina’s I believe. We ordered sandwiches. There’s a bakery, fresh market, shave Ice and ABC store just a short walk up the beach. We went to all of them at some point and we walked down the beach every time.Kevin owner of the condo was very friendly and kept us updated on happening that were taking place at the resort while we were there. We really appreciated his great communication and commitment to make our vacation wonderful! We highly recommend this condo and will return ourselves
Julie C.
August 2025
It was wonderful !! Everything went well! Love Sugar Beach
Dominique A.
August 2025
Beautiful condo with the most amazing hosts. After this stay, we will never stay anywhere but here. The unit had everything we needed. A couple of highlights, besides the super attentive hosts, were the California king bed and the amazing shower head. We spent many mornings drinking coffee and enjoying the direct oceanfront view and many afternoons enjoying the pool. Within walking distance to Sugar Beach Bakery, ABC Store, Ululani's Shave Ice and a great little farmers market.
Stacey R.
August 2025
We would highly recommend Sugar Beach Resort. We had everything we needed for our stay. Including a beach bag and coolers. We will definitely be staying here again when we return.
Michael M.
August 2025
Beautiful place with beautiful views
Derrick G.
August 2025
Great condo and overall property. It had all the comforts of home and convenience of being steps away from the beach. We would definitely consider staying again and recommending to others.
Ruby M.
August 2025
Easy check in, beautiful view, close to everything and a quiet beach! The condo was clean when we arrived and the host was quick to update us with anything happening at the condo. We will be back!
kyle v.
August 2025
The stay was very nice. The place was as described and as the pictures showed. Appreciated that the king bed was comfortable. The WiFi was good and fast. The kitchen was well stocked with the necessary items. The property manager was responsive. Location, location, location.
Chuck S.
August 2025
We had a great stay!
Sean G.
August 2025
Our stay was wonderful! Perfect location perfect condo! Thanks for everything!
Kristin K.
August 2025
Perfect
Mary G.
August 2025
We had a wonderful time, the condo is very cozy and comfortable…it had everything you needed and an absolute wonderful view. It was directly on the beach and had wonderful views of the sunset. You could go out the front door and a wonderful view of sunrise as well! Very convenient to stores, shops. we loved staying there and the check in/checkout process was a breeze. I would highly recommend !!
Sharon C.
August 2025
My husband and I stayed at this property for a few days on our honeymoon because we wanted to spend time in Kihei/closer to Wailea - we only stayed for two days, but you easily could stay for a week - inside the condo: it was spacious and perfect for the two of us with a large kitchen for cooking. The view is also incredible - just like the pictures! We sat on the balcony mornings, days, and nights - it's a destination in itself. The beach was also very quiet and perfect for walking or sitting in the sand. We saw lots of people swimming as well. Overall, I highly recommend this property if you're looking for something quiet, cozy, well-cared for, and on the ocean. It was worth the stay and we'd recommend it to all our family and friends!
Halley W.
August 2025
Wonderful condo on the ocean with pool and spa. Close to everything.
Ronald P.
August 2025
Beautiful property and condo…the location was great and we enjoyed the quieter area of the island and the beautiful beach. Condo was very comfortable and had everything we needed. The owners were great to work with and allowed us a later check out since our flight was in the evening.
Donna Y.
August 2025
It was great. Mike was very communicative and accommodating. Look forward to staying again.
Dora B.
August 2025
Communication and emails on time, access to the unit with door code super easy. Easy parking and centralized island location is perfect. Clean unit and well organized. The views all day long from this place as your temporary home make this place a 10 out of 10. My only regret was not booking the whole week here. Excellent place to stay! Highly recommend!
Tim C.
August 2025
Sugar beach is an amazing resort with a great beach. I walked forever and had the beach to myself! The unit is beautifully updated and fully stocked. We can’t wait to return.
Debbie G.
August 2025