The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Staying at Menehune Shores feels quintessentially oceanfront: you’re steps from the sand with sweeping lanai views of Maalaea Bay, nightly sunsets, and in-season whale sightings. A unique highlight is the historic rock fishpond right out front, which creates a shallow, protected lagoon that’s ideal for kids and calmer swims; sea turtles regularly rest on the rocks here. Guests love the quiet, well-kept grounds, heated pool (heater occasionally down), big grassy lawn, shuffleboard, and the panoramic rooftop with BBQs and a convivial sunset vibe. The North Kihei location is central for exploring Maui (Wailea, Haleakalā, Road to Hana, airport), yet feels laid back and uncrowded.
Condos vary by owner, but the overall theme is clean, comfortable, and well-equipped. Many units are updated and thoughtfully stocked with beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, snorkel sets), full kitchens, and in‑unit laundry; hosts and managers are frequently praised as responsive and accommodating. Some units have efficient mini‑split A/C in bedrooms/living areas, while others rely on trade winds, ceiling fans, and cross‑breezes; most guests report sleeping comfortably with windows open. Nice pluses: easy beach access, a quick walk to Kalepolepo Beach Park and the Humpback Whale Sanctuary, rooftop grilling, and an onsite Indian restaurant (Monsoon) that many enjoy.
Good to know: this is an older, well‑maintained complex, and individual units differ in décor and features—read the specific listing for A/C coverage, shade on the lanai, and recent updates. Afternoons can be windy, and the bay water here is often shallow and can look murkier than the postcard‑blue beaches; for clearer snorkeling or bigger waves, plan short drives to Wailea/Kapalua. Common nits mentioned across reviews include tight parking stalls and occasional road noise in end units, sporadic pool heater outages or maintenance closures (no hot tub), limited shade at the pool/roof, and the rare cleanliness or pest issue that’s typically addressed when reported. Overall sentiment is strongly positive: guests highlight the views, turtle encounters, central convenience, and family‑friendly setting—and many say they’d happily return.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
Excellent accommodations for our short stay before checking into another property. Chad was very responsive to messages, check in was a breeze, and the unit was very clean. The location was convenient for excursions to other parts of the island. Would definitely stay here again.
Eric S.
July 2026
We had a wonderful 2 week stay at the Kihei Coop. The condo was very well maintained and the kitchen was stocked with everything we needed to make our own meals. The beds were very comfortable and the curtains kept the room dark in the morning. The location was perfect as it's centrally located so it was only a 35 minute drive to Lahaina, 20 minutes to Costco and the airport, and 20 minutes to the resort area of Wailea. The hosts supply you with a great information website you can download to your phone that includes all the info you need about the condo and a guide to the areas beaches, shopping, and restaurants. Their communication throughout the two weeks was excellent. I would highly recommend staying at the Kihei Coop when visiting Maui. We hope to return in the future.
Ed F.
July 2026
Great location for the price. I wish this place had a AC… overall great!
Ahsas S.
July 2026
This was one of the best properties we have stayed at on the Islands! Steps away from the beach! A well maintained place and the communication with Jim was excellent! We will definitely be returning to this place to make sand castles with our granddaughter!!!
Ron G.
July 2026
We had an amazing time. The accommodations were very clean and inviting. The view was amazing! Looking forward to our next trip already.
Cliff L.
July 2026
We had a great time and the condo was good .
Suzanne B.
June 2026
Place was amazing for a family of 4. Very well equipped, with AC, comfortable beds, excellent location and with an great view
Ignacio J.
June 2026
Great property. Great host.
Michael C.
June 2026
Nice location!!
Rajesh G.
June 2026
Beautiful condo in Kīhei, check in was super easy and beds were very comfy! All the necessities provided. We enjoyed it!
Jeffrey B.
June 2026
The fan in the master bedroom was filthy. No air conditioning in the master bedroom. The master closet was a storage closet that smelt like paint. Could not use it. The beds were comfortable. Close to ship wreck beach.
sandy d.
June 2026
We loved our stay here! Great location, wonderful view, really nice pool!Wish we would have stayed in Maui longer, but would definitely stay here again!
Julie L.
June 2026
![Menehune Shores 503]()
From even prior to check in, Joe was extremely prompt with communication and information regarding the check in process, house expectations and any issues that arose. The bedrooms and bathrooms were very clean and when I noticed the dishwasher had a lot of buildup on the bottom, he sent out his cleaning crew the very next morning to address it. The pictures are pretty accurate of the property except the lighting wasn’t as bright as what the pictures depicted. The master shower has a curtain that you can open and look out to the beach. Great idea in theory, but when your partner is still sleeping in the morning and you want to use the washroom, the light is very bright through the curtain so the person sleeping is disturbed. I’m not sure if it was because of the high surf warnings, but the beach the condo is on was pretty full of debris. It was fine to walk and sit on, but I wouldn’t swim in it. The pool on the grounds was kept up extremely well. Every morning the grounds crew would clean the pool and all the grills on the property. And if anyone is concerned about the smell of the Indian restaurant on the first floor, it doesn’t smell at all in the apartment. The only time we were hit by the smell was when we got on or off the elevators so don’t let that deter you from booking. The condo is a three minute ride from a bunch of food trucks and most importantly, Kraken Coffee. It’s also a short drive to the Kam beaches and about 15-20 minutes from Wailea.
Shawna H.
June 2026
The property was perfect for our family of 5, the condo was very clean and well maintained and the complex was also very clean and well maintained. The location was easy to drive to other places, beaches and restaurants it was in a good location for that but I didn’t find it easy to walk to other beaches or restaurants. I would recommend this place to anyone, we truly enjoyed our stay and were very comfortable in the condo. Thank you for sharing your place so we could enjoy Maui.
Michelle L.
June 2026
The property was amazing! The host was very receptive to any questions we had. The view from the balcony was out of this world.
Mallory M.
June 2026
Tile floor was very dirty, nothing to clean with, beds need upgraded, very hard and uncomfortable, enjoyed the deck
William S.
June 2026
Very well described. Very nice accommodations. There was some noise from guests at night but that doesn't reflect on the owners. I would definitely stay here again.
connie d.
June 2026
The place was better than the pictures show. We would definitely return!
Kelli S.
June 2026
Great view! We appreciated all of the beach items that were available for us to use. It made our beach days perfect!
Noelle M.
June 2026
Great location! Condo was clean and well maintained.
Steph H.
June 2026
The room was fantastic! We had a problem with the air conditioner and contacted the host. Heard back from her immediately and she got the problem fixed. Beautiful beach in front. The only problem was mother nature brought a storm a few weeks before so our water was too murky to swim. But we still fot to see the turtles on our beach resting. All in all it was amazing
Allen L.
June 2026
The condo as a whole was a great location with a beautiful view and easy parking. The beds were very comfortable in both rooms with plenty of space. There is a nice breeze that comes through so you don’t need to use the AC hardly if you keep the blinds closed during the day to keep the heat out.. As the floors looked clean we all had very, very dirty feet within a couple hours of walking around the condo with no shoes.. That isn’t enough to not give a great review and we would absolutely stay again.
Desiree B.
June 2026
Wonderful view and so nice and close to pool and beach. Nice condo great facility!
Marcie D.
June 2026
This is a very nice ground floor unit in a central location with plenty of parking. We loved being right on the ocean with a beach just adjacent.The unit itself was very nice - comfortable beds, air conditioners in all rooms, and nice couches in the living room. The kitchen table was very large with lots of chairs which was perfect for all the games we played.The kitchen is very well stocked, with basic spices, foil & plastic wrap, and various condiments. And they also had laundry soap and dryer sheets which we really appreciated.There were boogie boards, beach toys, a couple beach chairs, a beach bag, and towels galore (no umbrella) available to bring to the beach.We were provided the number of a local property manager contact who was super responsive and answered various questions we had. Lastly, the owner was also easy to communicate with. Mahalo!!
Susan L.
June 2026
Ocean view was wonderful, condo was clean and close to stores and restaurants.
jon a.
June 2026
We had such an amazing time at the Kehei Coop! The space was clean, modern, and in a great location. We took road trips daily and had no problem as we were centrally located on the island. It was great having two bathrooms. The view was great and the balcony always had shade and a breeze. Beds were comfortable, shower was hot with great pressure, and the kitchen was stocked with appliances. The pool is warm and nicely maintained. The hosts are quick to reply to any question and had great recommendations for us. We highly recommend this condo for anyone visiting! Mahalo, we hope to return!
Paige G.
June 2026
We couldn't have asked for a better vacation. The condo was very comfortable, clean and convenient to beaches, restaurants and all things Maui! We are already planning on returning to Paradise in the near future! Special thanks to our hosts Helen and Mark for being so helpful! The Carroll Family
Maria C.
June 2026
Clean, comfortable, well stocked condo. Complex was nice.
Jennifer C.
June 2026
It was a perfect place to stay. The sight from the deck is gorgeous. The 2 bathrooms are a plus. The host is very accommodating….I would not hesitate to rent again this apartment.
Sd R.
June 2026
Beautiful condo!!! Clean, well stocked, great ocean view. Would definitely stay here again!
Katie L.
June 2026
Fun place to stay and a good location.
Joshua H.
June 2026
The room floors were not mopped, dirty. Had ants daily. For the price I expected better.
Joyce H.
June 2026
Generally after a longer vacation (especially with three young children), you might be a little ready to get back home to your comfort zone. Well, 605 was that comfort zone for us. We were all legitimately sad to leave and when we return to Maui, it will definitely be at the top of our list of places to stay. The hosts were incredibly kind and responsive through the whole process, and the condo was honestly more than we had even hoped for. Thank you!!!!!
Dan B.
June 2026
The view is stunning. The place has everything you need
Santiago G.
June 2026
Great condo in a convenient location. Loved the oceanfront lanai for sunrise and sunset views. The unit was well equipped in both the kitchen and for the beach with chairs and boogie boards. Would definitely recommend it and hope to come back ourselves.
Mark W.
June 2026
Having traveled throughout the country many times-what I can tell you about this property is that it was extremely clean, well run, pool-awesome, beach access-awesome, location to restaurants and activities -great. I appreciated the quiet hours. I took my grandkids on vacation with us-there were beach toys, fishing poles, towels, beach umbrella, and goggles to use. The kids had a great time! Amenities were all included and appreciated.
Donna W.
June 2026
Location: AmazingHost: Super responsive, patient and provided great information.Condo: Clean and perfect size for a family of 4.Building: GoodView: AmazingWould definitely recommend and stay here again if/when visiting in future.
Srinivas S.
June 2026
lanai view was excellent
DON P.
June 2026
Everything was excellent. Check in was easy. The pool is very nice. Rooms are comfortable and the kitchen was well stocked with everything you could need and more. View is nice of the beach and ocean. No complaints and couldn't be happier.
Jonathan P.
June 2026
We absolutely loved this condo and Chad was a wonderful host!! The view was incredible. Thank you for an awesome stay!
stephanie a.
June 2026
Great. Thank you
J J.
June 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Fab condo and super accommodating and helpful management company!
Gemma H.
June 2026
Super clean property, friendly staff and great excellent location!
Kim A.
June 2026
Nice room with great view. Convenient to all beaches.
Pam R.
June 2026
We really enjoyed our stay at this property! The proximity to the beach is great and Kihei is a quiet little town with a lot of great local restaurants with a WIDE variety of food offerings. The condo is well-maintained and really had everything we needed after a grocery store run. The rooftop area was great for sunsets and the lanai was small, but had a great view! Beds were comfortable, linens and towels were fine, coffee pot and full size fridge were great. Hosts were very responsive.
Leslie A.
June 2026
Condo was great for what we needed it for. Close in location to many shops and restaurants. Beds were very comfortable
ASHLEY B.
June 2026
![Menehune Shores 518]()
Our stay at Menehune Shores was absolutely wonderful! The condo was comfortable, clean, and well-maintained, making it feel like a home away from home. The bedrooms were cozy and inviting, and we had everything we needed for a relaxing and enjoyable vacation.The highlight of our stay was the incredible ocean view from the balcony. We were so close to the water that we could hear the waves rolling onto the shore throughout the day and night. Enjoying our morning coffee while watching the ocean was an experience we will never forget.Chad was an exceptional host. He was responsive, respectful, and attentive to all our inquiries. He made sure we had a great experience during our stay.I would highly consider returning to this condo and would recommend it to anyone visiting Maui. The location, comfort, breathtaking views, and outstanding hospitality made it the perfect place to stay. Although we traveled throughout the island, there is plenty of everything in Kīhei and nearby vicinity to make this location your primary destination.Mahalo from the Gimenez family from Southern California
Maria O.
June 2026
Really nice location close to (within a short driving distance) the restaurants and bars and stores. Beautiful views. More than enough room for the 5 people we had stay. The condos are very quite: you do not hear your neighbors at all. The beaches within walking distance to the left of the condo are rocky at the shoreline, and the rocked-in area has some big rocks you will stub your toe on as you wade out to see the turtles, but well worth it to see all of the turtles that come up on the beach. The water near the shore is murky on most days. We drove to lots of other beaches within 15-20 minutes south on South Kihei Road. South Kihei Road can get noisy, but it is usually not bad at all.
Tana D.
June 2026
The grounds at this property are meticulously maintained. The pool, chairs, grill… everything was perfectly scrubbed. The condo itself was well stocked with everything we could possibly need and the pictures are spot on. We loved being able to walk down and see the turtles in the morning. If it is your first time in Maui, plan your excursions for the afternoon so you can enjoy the calm beach weather in the morning.
Kimberly S.
June 2026
Absolutely beautiful property exactly as described. I’ve stayed at menehune shores before and it never disappoints. It’s a perfect location and super quiet I love being able to hear the waves. Such a beautiful home can’t wait to come back
Callie F.
June 2026