The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Most guests love Maui Banyan for its unbeatable South Kihei location. The resort sits just across the street from Kamaole Beach Park II, making sunrise swims, sunset viewing, snorkeling, and beach days effortless. It’s an easy walk to cafes, food trucks, and restaurants, and a short drive to Wailea, the airport, and island day trips—so it works well for both families and couples looking for a relaxed, highly walkable base.
The property has a friendly, resort-like vibe with two pools and hot tubs, spotless tropical landscaping, and plentiful, well‑kept BBQ areas. Many condos are updated, very clean, and thoughtfully stocked: full kitchens, in‑unit washer/dryers, beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, boogie boards), and the common 1BR/2BA layout gets frequent praise for convenience. Lanais range from garden and Haleakala views to partial ocean vistas; top floors and garden‑side units feel especially peaceful. Hosts are often cited as responsive and accommodating, with smooth check‑ins and occasional late checkouts.
Do note this is an older, individually owned condo complex, so units vary. While many feel newly refreshed, others come off dated or need deeper cleaning or minor maintenance. A handful of guests reported tropical pests (cockroaches/ants), occasional hiccups with entry codes, spotty Wi‑Fi, or AC units that are loud, on timers, or only in certain rooms. Pool‑facing units can be noisier, quiet hours are enforced, and periodic maintenance or construction may occur. Some buildings (like T) have no elevator, and garage parking stalls can be tight. If these matter, choose a recently renovated unit with strong reviews, confirm stair/elevator access and parking details with your host, and you’ll likely have an easy, comfortable stay in one of Kihei’s best-located resorts.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
Location was great being close to the beach and town.
Jo Y.
October 2025
There was a good view of the ocean from the unit we were in. Unit was was well supplied. From towels to kitchen utensils. Had everything a person would need to enjoy the beach. Beach chairs,umbrella boogieboards,ice chest and a wagon to get everything to the beach. Which was just across the street a short ways.
Robert S.
October 2025
From booking to check out, it was a flawless process. Upon entering the condo, it was very clean, organized and had everything we needed to have a successful and carefree vacation. It was very close to the pool for our nighttime swims and walking distance to the beach and restaurants. You don't have to worry about renting any snorkel hear as they have so many options as well as beach chairs and umbrella. We highly recommend staying here and we will be coming back soon!
Deborah L.
October 2025
Perfect place for us! Lots of space and all was in great condition! Host was super quick to respond to anything I asked! Really appreciated having nice Tommy Bahama beach chairs and umbrellas! Loved being right across the street from the beach! Couldn't have been better!!
Jody J.
October 2025
Very comfortable, convenient, very organized, quiet!Close to the beach and pool was just right. Mahalo for letting my family rent this place!
Kinoikaika R.
October 2025
Great location, we were able to easily walk to the beach and restaurants. Property was clean and worked well for our stay.
Ryan S.
October 2025
The tile floor was dirty. Walking in socks after taking shoes off the sock bottoms were very dirty. The second bath sink plunger did not work properly.
Bob E.
October 2025
Kitchen setup was great stools fit our needs perfectly.
Blaine I.
October 2025
Air conditioning was problematic with a twist timer dial that was not accurate. They would turn off in the middle of the night even though set for the 6 hrs. Advertising was slightly off in their description, which was disappointing.
Kelly S.
October 2025
It was great place to stay! Short walk to beach and it has a pool and hot tub! Definitely recommend to anyone!
Makenna M.
October 2025
Perfect location, lovely space and exactly what we needed! The only hiccup was that the check in process was a bit confusing with the involvement of the office on the property. But it all worked out!
Brenna C.
October 2025
Very clean room, beautiful view and the perfect host!Last nights view from the lanai!
Denise S.
October 2025
Great location, beach across the street. A perfect unit for our family. We had 4 adults and 2 children. It was well equipped with kitchen items for cooking. The fans provided were not in very good working order, the ac unit in the main room was fine though. I thought that the unit could have been cleaner and there were a few things that were in poor condition that the cleaners really should have noticed ( loose chair leg and loose door handle on patio) but fixed quite easily by my husband with a screw driver. Having said that - I would stay here again because the grounds/pool/location and any staff we encounter were all great. The host just was also very responsive to any of our queries. We did have a wonderful time.
Teresa H.
September 2025
Simple but perfect place. Location was amazing (not only across the beach but the actual condo is very close to the beach) Excellent communication and host was very accommodating. My only issue which was pretty minor is the sliding glass door that separates the room to the living room. I would recommend different curtains instead of the ones that are there now. But overall would definitely stay here again
Tina T.
September 2025
Beautiful. Peerfect location. Wonderful staff. Security was amazing.
Geraldine G.
September 2025
Roaches real bad! Property was stocked with everything you need. Neighbor smoked weed all day so you could smell that all day long.
Emily T.
September 2025
We loved the condo just as pictures showed. The location was perfect! Wonderful beach across the street!! Keep an eye out for the deer right across from the deck! Thank u!
Heide F.
September 2025
Wonderful stay at a very pretty condo in Kihei. Lovely furnishings and comfortable bed. Barb is a terrific host and made sure we had everything! Aloha! You"ll love it! Be sure to go to Road to Hana and Haleakala Crater. Awesome.
Joan E B.
September 2025
The check in and access to the property was very simple. The bed was comfortable and the bathrooms and kitchen were well stocked with the basics. The view from the lanai was perfect and sitting there so peaceful listening to the birds and swaying palm trees every morning.
Amie A.
September 2025
I have multiple sclerosis and am a wheelchair user that looked for ADA compliance. My wife and I were celebrating our 10th wedding anniversary, first time to Maui. We found the unit to be excellent! The unit was conducive to my needs. The parking garage was fun when we would return to the unit. Everything was beyond what we were expecting, which was already excellent!The views, the distance to local establishments, ease of check in and out, the staff, and Barb were simply amazing!We flew in on 9/9 and days before Hurricane Kiko was expected to hit the islands, which it thankfully did not, Barb was reaching out to update me and provided me info for local Maui weather! She is an excellent host!
William W.
September 2025
Very clean room and VRBO images mirrors reality
Bruno G.
September 2025
The location is truly the best for this area. Close to 3 beaches, restaurants are within walking distance. The staff at this facility treat you very well.Jack was in contact if needed (was not).The condo is well appointed and has everything you might want
Gary B.
September 2025
The condo was perfect for us !!! My husband and I stayed here for 10 days and we felt like at home. Location was exceptional and the condo was very comfortable and had everything we needed !!! Misty from Maui Gold Condos was fabulous to work with. She was extremely kind and helpful and quick to respond . If we could give 6 or more stars we would !!! Highly recommend
Celia B.
September 2025
Had a wonderful stay! We appreciated the good communication from the vrbo host and the recommendations they gave. We especially liked the ability to do laundry. We used the beach chairs to watch the sunset on the beach everyday (it was right across the street!). There are tiny ants which can be annoying and you must be really careful with food crumbs and leaving food out, but maybe a few extra ant traps/bait could help
Kayla B.
September 2025
2 bedroom condo in a great location, property grounds beautiful, condo clean and has almost everything you need.
Stanley f.
September 2025
Wonderful place to stay for our vacation! The location is perfect. We thoroughly enjoyed drinking our morning coffee on the beach and watching the sunset numerous times. Walking distance to whalers general store and the cinnamon roll place. The unit was clean, quiet, and had all the things we needed. Communication before our trip was also excellent.
Veronica C.
September 2025
Perfect for two people the rooms were clean not far from the beach. It was lovely.
Christine C.
September 2025
It was one of our nicest holidays, thanks to Jamie's hospitality and his Apartment functionality! Highly recommended!
Mirko J.
September 2025
The grounds were very well kept. Pool and jacuzzi were very clean. There was a beach a block away. Host allowed a late checkout.
David J.
September 2025
The property is so well maintained and the pools are so great. 1 bedroom is nice with a porch overlooking the property and with views of ocean and Haleakala. Air conditioning works really well ( loud but worth it) and fans are plentiful. We would come back.
Ellen M.
September 2025
The studio was spotless and well-equipped with everything you could possibly need. The hosts were very thoughtful in their accommodations, providing all the essentials to fully enjoy the beach. The property itself was quiet and peaceful, making it the perfect setting for a couple’s getaway. We truly enjoyed our stay and would definitely book again for our next trip. Thank y
KIM R.
September 2025
Location and views from the lanai were amazing. Place was very clean and updated. Grounds were kept everyday. Parking was easy.
Nikki S.
August 2025
![Maui Banyan T-205]()
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
I really appreciate all the thought that went into ensuring the condo was prepared for our family. Everything was clearly represented in the description, and there was a lot of care taken in the days leading up to our stay to ensure I understood how to check in, how to park, and also just routine check in to assure everything was going well. When I had a small issue with accessing the pool I got a response within 5 minutes even though it was after hours. The place was totally clean and equipped with shampoo, soap, toilet paper, paper towels, lots of beach, equipment, and beach towels. The common areas were beautiful, well-maintained and clean. Condo was super close to the beach (right across the street and perfect for kids) and within walking distance of restaurants. We were a family horror with two tweens staying with us. It was the perfect layout. And we would totally stay here again.
Kathleen H.
August 2025
It was perfect for me & my girlfriend check in/ out process was so easy pictures matched exactly what was on the app. Loved the accommodation of beach gear & coolers! Our host was very sweet & communicative. Would 100% book again.
Ricky L.
August 2025
We loved this location! It was the perfect size and close to a gorgeous beach. They had beach chairs, beach towels, a cooler. It was perfect! Would stay again!
Rachel P.
August 2025
Jack was an excellent host - responsive, accurate descriptions, and proactively ensuring we were prepared. Most importantly, this place actually has proper ocean views (unlike many others listed on this website). It was clean and had aloha ambiance/furnishings. Enjoy your time on the lanai because we will be back doing the same!
Ryan H.
August 2025
Everything about this room was perfect! The stocked kitchen, the comfy bed, spotless throughout...and the nicest hostess/manager you could ever meet!We will be back, for sure!
William W.
August 2025
Loved this place.
Barbara C.
August 2025
Our second stay in this beautiful condo! Just the best! We have only positive words to describe this unit. Comfy bed, everything you need in the kitchen, great beach stuff!! Thank you, again, Anthony and Julie! Aloha
William W.
August 2025
Great location! Right at the beach with turtles. Unit is clean and cute. Great communication! Owner gave us a very late checkout, which we appreciate greatly, as we had a overnight flight.
Ganna
August 2025
Love the place will book again
Anthony G.
August 2025
The great part of this property is the location: right across the street from Kamaole II. It has beautiful grounds, with a little fountain. The swimming pool was not bad. One downside of the apartment was the glass windows that separated the master bedroom from the pull out couch. That didn't give us a lot of privacy. I left some cardboard that I used to create privacy. There was a bit of a smell in the master bathroom. Cleaning of things like the shower wall and the vent above the toilet were poor. The big downside were the cockroaches. There were adults and nymphs in the kitchen, in the drawers, in the bathroom closest to the kitchen. The whole Maui Banyan property gets treatments every Wednesday, but obviously the pest control is ineffective. The tea kettle was a horrifying cemetery for cockroaches. I hope it gets replaced. We notified the manager and hope they improve this, and the manager was kind enough to process a small refund for our troubles.
Perry F.
August 2025
When traveling as a family of four with two older kids that can’t share a bed, options are usually slim. We were really lucky to come across this condo. Not only did both kids have their own queen sized bed, but they had their own room and bathroom and no one had to sleep on a pull out couch. Situated convenient to many of my favorite spots- Maluaka beach, Makena landing, 808 deli, ululani’s kihei, etc. this was a wonderful landing pad for our trip.
Breanna P.
August 2025
Great place in the Maui Banyan! Very clean and well stocked kitchen. Beach Chairs and Umbrella were a nice bonus!
Trevor T.
August 2025
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Very nice newly renovated apartment. Close to the beach. Nice pool area. With everything you might need during your stay.
Alan S.
August 2025
My friend and I were both impressed with the unit itself (clean, updated, well stocked) and its location (easy to walk, bus, and drive from)!Highly recommend, would go back!
Alexandra D.
August 2025
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
My husband and I really enjoyed our stay here. It was easy to check in and our entire stay felt comfortable and easy. The condo was clean and quiet and we got great sleep each night on the comfy king bed. The other guests and staff were all friendly. The quality of everything inside of the condo was great! We loved that there were beach items ready for us to borrow - Tommy Bahama beach chairs and umbrella. It was awesome to have two bathrooms, one even had a bidet. The washer/dryer combo worked well. Thanks for a lovely stay and we would love to stay in this condo again when we next visit.
A guest from Brunswick West, VIC
August 2025
Everything was wonderful! After getting in late we LOVED the welcome basket of snacks. Everything was exactly described. Already referred two friends to book. Kids loved the toys for the pool and beach. Will definitely visit again. Super quick walk to the beach and close to yummy restaurants.
Brittany and Daniel C.
July 2025
Attentive owners and great communication throughout. Only ding is that the Mattresses need upgrade (esp. King) but unit overall is excellent.
Robert M.
July 2025
A lovely condo - very well stocked! Great location. Thank you!
Francesca P.
July 2025