The following executive summary is based on a comprehensive and impartial AI analysis of guest reviews. Keep in mind that all units are individually owned, and review scores among units can vary considerably.
Most guests love Maui Banyan for its unbeatable South Kihei location. The resort sits just across the street from Kamaole Beach Park II, making sunrise swims, sunset viewing, snorkeling, and beach days effortless. It’s an easy walk to cafes, food trucks, and restaurants, and a short drive to Wailea, the airport, and island day trips—so it works well for both families and couples looking for a relaxed, highly walkable base.
The property has a friendly, resort-like vibe with two pools and hot tubs, spotless tropical landscaping, and plentiful, well‑kept BBQ areas. Many condos are updated, very clean, and thoughtfully stocked: full kitchens, in‑unit washer/dryers, beach gear (chairs, umbrellas, coolers, boogie boards), and the common 1BR/2BA layout gets frequent praise for convenience. Lanais range from garden and Haleakala views to partial ocean vistas; top floors and garden‑side units feel especially peaceful. Hosts are often cited as responsive and accommodating, with smooth check‑ins and occasional late checkouts.
Do note this is an older, individually owned condo complex, so units vary. While many feel newly refreshed, others come off dated or need deeper cleaning or minor maintenance. A handful of guests reported tropical pests (cockroaches/ants), occasional hiccups with entry codes, spotty Wi‑Fi, or AC units that are loud, on timers, or only in certain rooms. Pool‑facing units can be noisier, quiet hours are enforced, and periodic maintenance or construction may occur. Some buildings (like T) have no elevator, and garage parking stalls can be tight. If these matter, choose a recently renovated unit with strong reviews, confirm stair/elevator access and parking details with your host, and you’ll likely have an easy, comfortable stay in one of Kihei’s best-located resorts.
This summary is based on a comprehensive analysis of 1000 reviews
This condo was adequate. Overall it had a feel of dinginess, however. Could us some fresh paint, new pillows, sweep/mop floors a bit better. The bathroom mirror is scratched so that it always blurry. The closet is so full you can’t hang your clothes.
Melissa P.
February 2026
When we arrived at 4 pm the room had not been cleaned. I was ill and laid on the couch while 3 people scurried around and tried to clean it up. It took a while but was very uncomfortable for us.
Joy F.
February 2026
Perfect location. Easy check-in and nice amenities.
Gilbert M.
February 2026
We loved staying here! Our host had a beautiful place for us to stay. We were able to text them and they responded quickly. Such a cute place to stay , very comfortable and right across the street from one of our favorite beaches. They offered umbrellas, beach chairs, coolers and boogie boards for us to use. We appreciated and used them every day. We will definitely book with this host again.
Medalie R.
February 2026
everything great !!
Charlie N.
February 2026
We had an amazing stay! This was the best unit that we have ever rented!! It was super clean and the kitchen was so well stocked with everything we needed. As an added bonus the knifes were actually sharp! Never has happened in a VRBO before.
Lisa A.
February 2026
This place was perfect, the updated kitchen was full of everything you’d need to cook at home, the location can’t be beat with the Kamole beaches less than a minute walk away, and the host was very responsive and helpful in completing the booking.
Samuel N.
February 2026
Great location and accommodations! Literally 2-3 minute walk to the beach, access to washer and dryer was amazimg as well as fridge to store my Leoda's pies! Planning to come again and if this condo is available would book again!
Kneeley B.
February 2026
Was a great place to stay. Had everything for the Maui experience. Loved it.
Clint G.
February 2026
Nice location
wesley h.
February 2026
Great
Frank A.
February 2026
Jack was great to work with.
Ryan O.
February 2026
Location to beach, Kīhei restaurants, views. Host responded well to questions. Unit is clean.
Julie J.
January 2026
Great location. Great host.
Ronna M.
January 2026
We rented this unit for our daughter in law and infant grandson to stay in while visiting us. It was a great location as she could see the ocean from the lanai and the front door. It was her first visit to Maui so this made it special. She had everything she needed, including a pack and play for the baby. It was as a cozy space for her to be when she wasn’t spending time with us.
Colleen R.
January 2026
Everything was perfect!
Colleen V.
January 2026
Great communication and responsiveness.
Alexis K.
January 2026
We loved the view of the mountain and the ocean from the balcony
Greg M.
January 2026
Clean, comfortable, with a great view
Katherine P.
January 2026
Location was clean and stocked. The pull out bed was a little rough for an adult to sleep on, but overall enjoyable location. A drying rack would have been a great addition as we frequently had wet towels and swimsuits.
Marci P.
January 2026
Everything about our stay at Misty’s Maui Banyon studio was great … the location, the ease of access, the cleanliness, and the overall comfort. We hope to come back!
Janet M.
January 2026
Bad mattress and no cable ; internet extremely slow and no instructions for use of televisions
Marcel D.
January 2026
I received all the support I needed from the Host and enjoyed having the use of the beach furniture and some of the seasonings in the pantry.
Lynn A.
January 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
The condo was as outlined by the owner and was ready for our arrival. The location was great with quaint shops, excellent food within walking distance, and the beach right across the street. We enjoyed our stay and will visit again! I would recommend the front loading washing machine get a good cleaning. If the guests don’t leave the door open after running a wash cycle, mold develops.
Gray P.
January 2026
What a lovely experience this was. The location was amazing. The unit was very clean and spacious. The owner was lovely to deal with right from day one. The kitchen has everything you need. There was sand toys and chairs etc. we left more sand toys so there is an abundance now lol. I can’t wait to stay here again!
Candice H.
January 2026
We had an amazing stay at this condo! The room was very clean and comfortable, we were a family of 5, it had all the amenities you would need!The management was pleasant and accommodating from beginning to end. The location of this condo was perfect. Most nights we walked across the street to Kam 2 to watch the beautiful sunsets.. Every morning we walked to get coffee at the Java Lava & Cinnamon buns at the viral Cinnamon bun shop! Lots of good restaurants in the area. The Kīhei Food truck oasis was also a big hit most nights for dinner. We would definitely look to stay here again when we return!!
liz t.
January 2026
The place was modern, clean and bright. Loved the view, the privacy, the easy beach access and the seamless check-in/out
Morgan T.
January 2026
The bedroom AC was great, it was clean, and I would stay there again. The only issue would be (if I wasn’t alone) a lack of privacy. The inside doors are sliding and the bathroom door doesn’t latch or lock.
Henry D.
January 2026
Second trip to Kihei. Absolutely loved this condo. Location is perfect. super clean. Lisa was accommodating and responsive. She was a joy to work with. The small things are what really added to the experience. Meaning there were basic condiments available cleaning supplies some paper products so after a long trip, shopping was less urgent. And when you’re on vacation, anything that makes things less urgent adds to the experience. If I were to own a short term rental, this is how I’d like it managed.
Otavio B.
January 2026
We were pleased with the accommodations. Beach chairs were a pleasant surprise. The host was prompt in responding to question we had. Only negative may be if sensitive to sounds air conditioner in bedroom little noisy, though by use of air conditioner in living area and ceilling fans we were comfortable. Beach, stores, food easily within walking distance. We would look forward to staying again.
Jeanne J.
January 2026
Very welcoming and knowledgeable host. Great location
Timothy C.
January 2026
This place was great! Very clean and stocked with all the basics needed for the length of our stay. I would definitely stay there again!
Melissa F.
January 2026
Great location, minutes to a family-friendly beach. Spacious kitchen and family room, and master suite. Nice to have two TVs with cable and streaming for evenings. Big balcony. I would recommend upgrading the sliding doors for the balcony, as well as some of the pocket doors (didn't slide easily), and the master shower (Hard to get into, old with poor water pressure)
Pramvir V.
January 2026
Great Location. Cindi had everything we needed.
Draga F.
January 2026
a nice box of chocolates was wanting for us after our flight. a pleasant surprise!
Kenderson U.
January 2026
Host was very welcoming and good communication. Room is dated but cozy with a grear location! Hot water and wifi were hit and miss and the bathroom sink plug needs to be fixed we had to keep it open with a knife so it would drain. We enjoyed out stay
Nissa G.
January 2026
Excellent location, the condo has everything we needed, very clean and easy to check in and out. We will definitely return.
Krista
January 2026
Host forgot we were coming and didn’t schedule a cleaning. We waited 30 minutes after check in calling host to finally let us in.Place had small bugs all over the kitchen counters and cabinets.
Tarantino
January 2026
We loved staying at Anne’s VRBO. We got to meet her as we were coming in and she was very pleasant and let us know to reach out if we needed anything. Luckily we did not as the studio had everything we needed. The studio was just exactly as pictured, and in a good location with beaches and lots of food options nearby. Studio was also stocked with extra towels, beach chairs, cups, dishes, etc. The AC also works great. We will definitely stay here again. Thanks Anne!
dinora e.
January 2026
Excellent place for vacation! Host was very helpful!
Irina Y.
January 2026
Having stayed in H308 before we knew what to expect. Comfortable, unbelievably stocked and great view. Our only disappointment were the bugs. They were not errible, but I probably killed a couple of dozen roaches over the course of our stay. That being said, we also understand how difficult they are to control on the islands.
Mike M.
January 2026
Great location close to the beach, and had lots of beach accessories to use.
Cory W.
January 2026
Great stay
sarah v.
January 2026
Everything was just wonderful!!! Added surprise was to see the New Years Eve Fireworks from the lanai! Thank you so much for hosting our stay in your amazing condo!
Dawn H.
January 2026
Its location is very convenient to awesome beaches and walkable to food and shopping. Pools are smaller , condo a little dated but comfortable and had everything we needed.
Stacie S.
January 2026
Very good nice location host contact very good
Yuna c.
January 2026
Our second time staying at this amazing condo. There is absolutely everything you need including an exceptionally well stocked kitchen with all the dinnerware and appliances you could possibly need. Probably the best kitchen in all the condos we have ever stayed in. The beach across the road is amazing, the bed including the sofa bed are very comfortable, onsite undercover parking is fantastic. The 2 pool and spa areas never seemed too crowded and was very handy when conditions at the beach were too windy.Looking forward to booking this condo again next time we come to Maui.
Melissa Z.
January 2026
Anna was an excellent host. Super quick to respond to messages or questions. The place was fully stocked and a perfect home for the week. Comfortable,quiet and very close to the beaches. We will be back!
Jennifer C.
December 2025
Wonderful place!
sarah v.
December 2025
Kitchen was fully equipped. Sheets were soft and bed was very comfortable. Spacious. Loved two bathrooms and privacy of bedroom from living room. Lanai had great feeling of spacious surroundings and was private from other guests. Didnt need air conditioning and quiet at night
gretchen h.
December 2025